Jamesaritchie said:
And how, exactly, does a wolf behave? I've been around wolves for most of my life, and I still can't tell you how a wolf behaves. Wolves are as individual as people, and "wolf behavior" is, at best, a broad generalization. It's like saying people should always be people. Fine, but it really says nothing.
Of course, wolves are individuals. So is every one of my dogs. However, the chance that a dog will behave exactly like a wolf is like saying that a frog will behave like a snake. After all, they're both reptiles, aren't they?
There are certain patterns of behavior that a creature follows according to its species' nature. A wolf will behave in a manner that is conducive to being a WOLF. It will not behave like a tiger. The environment and prey are essentially different, therefore the behavior will not be the same, even though both are predators.
I've had the great honor of studying dog behavior for close to fourty-four years. Yes, within the species individual behavior will differ, but it will always center on one thing -- survival within the existing environment. Creatures that are unable to exist within their environment die out. It's that simple.
Canines have insinuated themselves into just about every niche going. They are extremely adaptable. They are survivors.
And fantasy is just that. . .fantasy. All sorts of things come into play that would affect the behavior of a wolf, or any other creature.
As has already been pointed out, fantasy works best when a bit of reality is seeded in the soil. It gives the reader a point of reference and some empathy with the character.
The same goes for art, I've found. As a student of animals -- their behavior and movement -- I find it very upsetting to see how animals are portrayed, sometimes in poses that are frankly impossible for their bodies to attain or hold under the confines of gravity. Anyone who's ever looked at Currier and Ives prints will know what I mean. Sure. It's the style, but it annoys me that the horses are flying.
Horses, for instance, during their gallop have only one instance of suspension, while sighthounds and cheetahs have two.
Please, people! When using animals in your stories, add a little reality! That's a cheque you can cash at my bank anytime.