Interesting article. The presence of free oxygen -- not bound up into CO2, H2O, or minerals -- is a likely signature of life. But, simulations suggest there's ways for solar radiation to break CO2 molecules faster than the free oxygen could recombine -- a non-biological origin of an oxygen signature.
Scientists Debate Signatures of Alien Life
Scientists Debate Signatures of Alien Life
Quanta Magazine said:As future telescopes widen the survey of Earth-like worlds, it’s only a matter of time before a potential biosignature gas is detected in a faraway sky. It will look like the discovery of all time: evidence that we are not alone. But how will we know for sure?
Scientists must quickly hone their models and address the caveats if they are to select the best exoplanets to target with the James Webb telescope. Because of the hundreds of hours it will take to examine the spectrum for each planetary atmosphere and the many competing demands on its time, the telescope will likely only observe between one and three earthlike worlds in the habitable “Goldilocks” zones of nearby stars. In choosing from a growing list of known exoplanets, the scientists want to avoid planetary circumstances in which oxygen false positives arise. “We’re looking at maybe putting our eggs, if not all in one basket, at least in only a couple of baskets,” Meadows said, “so it’s important to try and figure out what we should be looking for there. And in particular, how we might get fooled.”
...