Hi Everyone,
I'm deep into my research for my historical mystery series, but I couldn't seem to find a straight answer to this question so hopefully there are some experts here who might know.
In my book, one of the suspects has been corresponding with the murder victim with letters (this is set in the past before email). The letters aren't love letters but more notes arranging for meetings. One of the main pieces of evidence for the case against this suspect is that the last note he got from the victim was asking him to meet her at a certain time which was established as the time of death.
My question is, while I know the police would need to hold that last note as evidence, would they also need to hold the other notes? They did take them and examine them but right now in my book I have them having given them back to the suspect (all except the last one, of course). Would that be feasible?
From what I could find out in my research, it's not a straight yes or no. For example, in a film that I saw set in the 1940s, the police took some love letters from a woman who had been corresponding with a man they suspect of committing a crime (not murder, though). They took the letters to examine them and they gave them back to her soon after. I know it's not the same situation, but I'm wondering if, since the letters don't directly have to do with the murder itself (since they were written well before it) and serve mainly to establish a relationship between the suspect and murder victim (but don't have a direct bearing on the motive for the crime), would they be returned?
Thanks for the help!
Tam
I'm deep into my research for my historical mystery series, but I couldn't seem to find a straight answer to this question so hopefully there are some experts here who might know.
In my book, one of the suspects has been corresponding with the murder victim with letters (this is set in the past before email). The letters aren't love letters but more notes arranging for meetings. One of the main pieces of evidence for the case against this suspect is that the last note he got from the victim was asking him to meet her at a certain time which was established as the time of death.
My question is, while I know the police would need to hold that last note as evidence, would they also need to hold the other notes? They did take them and examine them but right now in my book I have them having given them back to the suspect (all except the last one, of course). Would that be feasible?
From what I could find out in my research, it's not a straight yes or no. For example, in a film that I saw set in the 1940s, the police took some love letters from a woman who had been corresponding with a man they suspect of committing a crime (not murder, though). They took the letters to examine them and they gave them back to her soon after. I know it's not the same situation, but I'm wondering if, since the letters don't directly have to do with the murder itself (since they were written well before it) and serve mainly to establish a relationship between the suspect and murder victim (but don't have a direct bearing on the motive for the crime), would they be returned?
Thanks for the help!
Tam