How long until blood vanishes?

SuspiciousCookie

Deliciously Ominous
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Apr 12, 2013
Messages
666
Reaction score
57
Location
Krashoire
Website
athousandkeystrokes.wordpress.com
Okay, this feels like something I should know and it feels like an extremely silly question, but I'll ask it anyway. All right, here you go:

So, in my book there's a place in the woods where there's been a bloody fight. Oh, just to clarify: It's a fantasy kind of story, so arrows were shot, not bullets. Not sure if that would make a difference anyway.
Now, a certain time after, during the events of the actual book, my protagonist stumbles upon that place. The idea is that he stumbles upon the bloodstains and wonders about what the hell happened here.

Now, the question is: How long does it take until the bloodstains are not visible anymore on the bark of the trees (obviously, rain, mud and snow are gonna wash away any stains on the ground quite quickly), and what factors play a role here? For example, the tilt of the trunk, the amount of rainfall and snow, ... ?

I looked for answers on Google, but unfortunately, Google was not my friend this time around, as most articles (naturally) were about more mundane issues - like crusty blood on the skin.

Cheers and thanks in advance!
 

lbender

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Aug 24, 2010
Messages
1,009
Reaction score
119
Location
Maryland
I can't give you a definitive answer, but there are other factors that will affect the time besides precipitation.

For example, what climate and time of year are we talking about? If you're in the middle of winter and it's icy, the blood will last longer than in the height of summer because of bacterial and fungal growth, not to mention insect concentrations.

What kind of wildlife hangs out there and how abundant are they? Is there some critter around that might just come and lap up the blood?

These are just 2 possible variables that might affect your timing. You might very well be able to fiddle with the conditions enough to arrange for various answers.

ETA - The type of tree might also affect it. Blood might show up longer against the white of a birch tree, for example.
 
Last edited:

Drachen Jager

Professor of applied misanthropy
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Mar 13, 2010
Messages
17,171
Reaction score
2,284
Location
Vancouver
Animals will be one of the first things to get at it. Lots of rich food there. Insects mostly, but some larger animals too.

Depending mostly on how dry it is and the amount of life in the forest, I'd give it a week or two. Maybe a little more during certain seasons.

This is just my own haphazard guess though. Nothing scientific to back my opinion up.
 

melindamusil

practical experience, FTW
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Nov 6, 2012
Messages
743
Reaction score
65
I'm totally guessing, but I would imagine that "soft" wood trees (like maple) would be more absorbent than "hard" wood trees (like oak). Thus they may retain the blood longer.
 

King Neptune

Banned
Joined
Oct 24, 2012
Messages
4,253
Reaction score
372
Location
The Oceans
Unless it soaked into rocks that contained no micro-organisms, bacteria, etc. would eat it with a short time. I can't imagine any being in the soil after a week, and trees would absorb it at about the same rate, but there might be a stain left in wood. If it wasn't all gone within a week in the Summer, then there would be stains that would remain for years.
 

espresso5

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Apr 23, 2012
Messages
146
Reaction score
14
Just a guess, but in a typical deciduous forest, I'm guessing most of it would be gone in two or three days. If a tree had smooth bark and was a lighter color, it might be possible for residual stains to last considerably longer.
Other evidence of a fight-turned up ground, broken brush, etc, might last for a few weeks, depending on the amount of rain and type of undergrowth.
 

SuspiciousCookie

Deliciously Ominous
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Apr 12, 2013
Messages
666
Reaction score
57
Location
Krashoire
Website
athousandkeystrokes.wordpress.com
Thanks for all your answers so far.

I probably should have clarified this before, but we're actually talking about several years after this fight. So,

1. Is there any possibility for bloodstains to last for that long (King Neptune hinted something like that, but I'd like a more extensive description if possible)?
2. If yes, what conditions would be required for that?
3. If no, do you have any other ideas for indicators of a fight that last for years, other than bloodstains?

Cheers, and again, thanks in advance.

P.S.: There are boards where you are contemptuously talked to just because the question you asked is a little silly or because you forgot details necessary to answer. I'm really glad this doesn't appear to be one of these boards. :)
 

evilrooster

Wicked chicken
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Dec 8, 2010
Messages
3,082
Reaction score
888
Location
Where eggs are small and dear
Website
www.sunpig.com
You're really not likely to have noticeable bloodstains around for several years. Maybe, just maybe, if a piece of dead wood were lying around and got splashed, the mark would be findable -- but forest clearings are complex places, full of years of fallen leaves turning to leafmould, relatively non-absorbent bark, and rocks already covered in lichen. The proportion of absorbent surfaces that could show bloodstains is relatively low.

(I've bled in a forest. Even knowing where it was, when I went back the next day I only managed to find one fallen leaf with a drop of dried blood on it.)

My suggestion would be to use a combination of mechanical damage (sword-cuts to the trunks of trees, for instance, would leave quite long-lasting marks) and remaining artifacts (even if the reusable arrows are collected, broken ones are likely to be left in place). Find a few arrowheads half-embedded in trees, and you know something happened there. Then all you have to do is differentiate it from hunting: two different kinds of fletching/arrowhead, military arrowheads rather than the ones common people carry, laws restricting hunting in that wood, etc. And sword-cuts would be pretty hard to ignore as hunting accidents.
 

Sonata

Kind Benefactor
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Feb 28, 2013
Messages
54
Reaction score
6
You're really not likely to have noticeable bloodstains around for several years. Maybe, just maybe, if a piece of dead wood were lying around and got splashed, the mark would be findable -- but forest clearings are complex places, full of years of fallen leaves turning to leafmould, relatively non-absorbent bark, and rocks already covered in lichen. The proportion of absorbent surfaces that could show bloodstains is relatively low.

(I've bled in a forest. Even knowing where it was, when I went back the next day I only managed to find one fallen leaf with a drop of dried blood on it.)

My suggestion would be to use a combination of mechanical damage (sword-cuts to the trunks of trees, for instance, would leave quite long-lasting marks) and remaining artifacts (even if the reusable arrows are collected, broken ones are likely to be left in place). Find a few arrowheads half-embedded in trees, and you know something happened there. Then all you have to do is differentiate it from hunting: two different kinds of fletching/arrowhead, military arrowheads rather than the ones common people carry, laws restricting hunting in that wood, etc. And sword-cuts would be pretty hard to ignore as hunting accidents.

I second. That's exactly what I was going to suggest. A buried broadhead in tree bark might be visible, but not fall out for years.

Probably not helpful, but a trained canine can detect blood scent for years after, so traces of blood would still be there technically, just probably not visible. I've tracked deer the morning after it was shot and you'd be amazed at how well a forest can hide that and how quickly that trail vanishes, especially if there's inclement weather.

Side note: Blood also dries almost black, not red; very dark brown would be an acceptable description too. I've seen that mistake made before.
 

King Neptune

Banned
Joined
Oct 24, 2012
Messages
4,253
Reaction score
372
Location
The Oceans
Thanks for all your answers so far.

I probably should have clarified this before, but we're actually talking about several years after this fight. So,

1. Is there any possibility for bloodstains to last for that long (King Neptune hinted something like that, but I'd like a more extensive description if possible)?
2. If yes, what conditions would be required for that?
3. If no, do you have any other ideas for indicators of a fight that last for years, other than bloodstains?

Without knowing the terrain it is impossible to know what signs of a fight might remain after several years. What kind of vegetation is there? What are the soil and rocks like? What is the climate?

One way would be for the vegetation to be permanently damaged. If there were shrubs, yew, juniper, and similar, that live for a long time, then breaking branches, etc. would be apparent for years after. There are rocks that could absorb and hold blood stains for many years, but they probably wouldn't be identifiable as blood, just as brownish stains.

In addition to the local conditions, the kind of fight would also make a difference. There are remains from ancient battles in some places.


Cheers, and again, thanks in advance.

P.S.: There are boards where you are contemptuously talked to just because the question you asked is a little silly or because you forgot details necessary to answer. I'm really glad this doesn't appear to be one of these boards. :)
It isn't?
 

Princess Marina

Princess Marina
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Mar 5, 2013
Messages
288
Reaction score
17
Location
Isle of Man
Quote:
Originally Posted by SuspiciousCookie
Thanks for all your answers so far.

I probably should have clarified this before, but we're actually talking about several years after this fight. So,

1. Is there any possibility for bloodstains to last for that long (King Neptune hinted something like that, but I'd like a more extensive description if possible)?
2. If yes, what conditions would be required for that?
3. If no, do you have any other ideas for indicators of a fight that last for years, other than bloodstains?

If you are talking forensically blood stains can last a lot longer than a couple of years although DNA might break down and be incapable of comparison. However on growing wood fresh bark would grow over any cuts or blood stains in that period. So slashes to the trees would have to be deep. Broken branches would remain but would be less noticeable as fresh growth came in. Churned earth would have reseeded and unless artifacts from the battle remained and hadn't been looted in a couple of years the only noticeable effects would be the ground would be more fertile and the growth over dead bodies tends to be more lush. Blood and bone being an excellent feriliser.
 
Last edited:

SuspiciousCookie

Deliciously Ominous
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Apr 12, 2013
Messages
666
Reaction score
57
Location
Krashoire
Website
athousandkeystrokes.wordpress.com
Okay, I think I may or may not have made a decision now.

Sword cuts and similar wouldn't be there, because, well, it wasn't a sword fight. Thinking about it, it wasn't much of a fight at all. More like a surprise arrow-in-the-bones issue, if you know what I mean. But I suppose there could be an arrow that didn't exactly find its target, and it just so happened it got stuck in a dark enough tree so the bandits couldn't find it erasing their traces, and it coincidentally happened to just sit there until my protagonist finds it. Sounds good.

King Neptune said:
It isn't?

Well, not as far as I have seen until now. Of course, I may have just gotten lucky until now. Or I am just such a charming and friendly cookie that everyone wants to be my friend. Both options are entirely plausible.

Cheers and thanks again,
and I guess, if nobody has anything else to add, this thread can be closed then, no?
 

GeorgeK

ever seeking
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jul 17, 2007
Messages
6,577
Reaction score
740
Judging from my butchering gazebo, in Kentucky spring through fall, just a couple days even without rain and the bugs and birds have removed the stains. Winter is another thing, probably a couple weeks. Also a tailgate in a garage, it will take a couple months
 

WeaselFire

Benefactor Member
Kind Benefactor
Super Member
Registered
Joined
May 17, 2012
Messages
3,539
Reaction score
429
Location
Floral City, FL
Now, the question is: How long does it take until the bloodstains are not visible anymore on the bark of the trees (obviously, rain, mud and snow are gonna wash away any stains on the ground quite quickly), and what factors play a role here?
Just punch yourself in the nose and bleed a little on the lawn, in the woods, etc. Then observe.

(Okay, you can usually buy blood at a butcher shop to test this too...)

Jeff