How many queries do you send out at one time? Do you start from the top of your wish list, or test the waters first?
I usually send out a test batch to agents I like and know respond fairly-ish quickly. I start with 5, might go to 10. Depending on their response to my query, I either revise or start sending more aggressively, including to my favorite agents. But I've stopped taking a good query response as an excuse to query everyone all at once, because then you still might get notes with rejections that you want to implement and not having queried everyone so quickly leaves you agents to query after revisions in that case.
Interesting. Thank you all so much for your responses -- keep them coming! I'm finally at the ready-to-query stage!
For me:
Start at the top of your list. If you get an offer, you're not going to have time to rush and query your "first picks" after the fact.
Start with small batches of 5-10. If you get a rejection, then you can either send out another query, or wait to see how many rejections come in. If they're all rejections, then you might need to tweak things for your next round of queries.
Don't get so worried about dream agents. Unless you're in a very narrow genre, there are probably dozens of agents (or more) that could represent you well. I e-query at least ten at a time, maybe 15. Half you will never hear from. Of those you do hear from, at least half will be form rejections. Of those who request, half you will never hear from. So out of 15 queries, you may have one or two who, if they pass (and they probably will) might give you some good feedback.
The first time I had a full MS requested I was so excited. The first time I had someone ask for an exclusive, I was so excited. Then they both passed. It is tough out there. Don't pin all your hopes on a few "dream agents." Query widely.
I like this approach. I said test the waters because I blew most of my dream agents in my first (bad) query and unrevised manuscript. (I thought it was done. Newbie mistake.)I simple filter the list of agents by my genre, and go through them alphabetically (random would be even better.) Each query batch gets some great ones, some OK, some I probably don't want.
Why? Because the other options don't work. If your query is bad at the start, and you use up all your grade A agents, you're screwed. If your query is great, and you get a ton of offers from agents who you were testing the waters with, it sucks (are you going to turn them all down, and frantically send out a new batch of queries to your best agents?) Seems like a diverse group gives you the most feedback; the best odds of success, especially if you are a new author who isn't confident of their own abilities yet.
I simple filter the list of agents by my genre, and go through them alphabetically (random would be even better.) Each query batch gets some great ones, some OK, some I probably don't want.
Why? Because the other options don't work. If your query is bad at the start, and you use up all your grade A agents, you're screwed. If your query is great, and you get a ton of offers from agents who you were testing the waters with, it sucks (are you going to turn them all down, and frantically send out a new batch of queries to your best agents?) Seems like a diverse group gives you the most feedback; the best odds of success, especially if you are a new author who isn't confident of their own abilities yet.
True facts right here. Whatever you do, do not pin your hopes on dream agents. Don't google them when they request a full and find out that they have a summer home in Martha's Vineyard and day dream for days and days about how after you've won your Pulitzer and y'all are great friends you'll be sitting on the balcony of that house looking out at the sunset on the water and drinking wine while you two laugh about how a silly query brought you to that point.
Whatever else you do, do not do this.
I've queried a few dozen agents in this second round of querying. This is probably going to be my last gasp, on this book, anyway. After hearing so many people say they queried 150 agents before getting an offer, I want to make sure my query crosses the desk of every agent who seems like a possible match.
Do people think this is a bad idea?
I've worked on this damn book for six years, and I've just spent the last year rewriting, and I don't think I have it in me to do it again. So if they don't like it now, I guess it won't matter if I've used up my chances (I stopped after 17 queries the first time so as not to do that).