- Joined
- Nov 19, 2011
- Messages
- 4,910
- Reaction score
- 279
Okay, even though this post could just as easily go in the Romance forum, I felt that it was still better suited here. This recently came up in a group for IR Romance I'm in on GoodReads. As most people know, Historical Fiction is a genre itself. Then naturally, Regency Romance/Historical Romance are sub-genres of Romance.
In the discussion, a lot of the replies were saying that those readers did not like Historical IR Romance. Not necessarily due to the fact that it was historical, but more so due to the racial tensions that surround either the situation or the couple. For example, most of the books or stories that the members of the group either hated or weren't comfortable took place during the American/U.S. slavery-era and typically involved the slave owner(or a relative of the slave owner) falling in love with one of the female slaves wherever the book was set.
I'm not trying to cause any issues or trouble or anything but I just felt this would be an interesting topic to discuss. How do you feel about putting PoCs in a racially tumultuous era or time period? I know that sounds like an easy question to answer but I want this to apply to both general Historical Fiction(or Historically-themed Fiction) and Historical Romance. Do you depict the era how the research that was done does or do you only put in so much of it and leave out some?
Also do you think a character's race or ethnicity could affect the type of story that is told or have an effect on the plausibility or believability of the story being told? For example, do you think it's possible to have Regency-era or around Regency-era Interracial Romance where one character was "fully" whatever racial background is chosen, meaning, again, for example, the character is fully black or white, not a mix.
So, to repeat, how do you feel about Historical and Regency Interracial stories? And do you think that because one of the main characters, if not the main character, is a PoC it affects the story being told?
Again, this is just fun discussion. No harm was meant by the questions. I just wanted to ask to get different opinions.
Note: I don't write in either Historical Fiction or Historical Romance. However, I was still curious about the topic.
In the discussion, a lot of the replies were saying that those readers did not like Historical IR Romance. Not necessarily due to the fact that it was historical, but more so due to the racial tensions that surround either the situation or the couple. For example, most of the books or stories that the members of the group either hated or weren't comfortable took place during the American/U.S. slavery-era and typically involved the slave owner(or a relative of the slave owner) falling in love with one of the female slaves wherever the book was set.
I'm not trying to cause any issues or trouble or anything but I just felt this would be an interesting topic to discuss. How do you feel about putting PoCs in a racially tumultuous era or time period? I know that sounds like an easy question to answer but I want this to apply to both general Historical Fiction(or Historically-themed Fiction) and Historical Romance. Do you depict the era how the research that was done does or do you only put in so much of it and leave out some?
Also do you think a character's race or ethnicity could affect the type of story that is told or have an effect on the plausibility or believability of the story being told? For example, do you think it's possible to have Regency-era or around Regency-era Interracial Romance where one character was "fully" whatever racial background is chosen, meaning, again, for example, the character is fully black or white, not a mix.
So, to repeat, how do you feel about Historical and Regency Interracial stories? And do you think that because one of the main characters, if not the main character, is a PoC it affects the story being told?
Again, this is just fun discussion. No harm was meant by the questions. I just wanted to ask to get different opinions.
Note: I don't write in either Historical Fiction or Historical Romance. However, I was still curious about the topic.
Last edited: