- Joined
- Nov 14, 2005
- Messages
- 37
- Reaction score
- 1
I just spent some time on an interesting blog. One recommended by the knowsy-knows on the board here. (that was not meant in any sort of derogatory way)
In the blog there was a posted response from a well-established editor at a well-recognised company in regards to good/bad agents, and whether they're necessary at all.
Without naming any names, or posting direct quotes, because I don't want to point fingers, and in general I really liked the article, and the editor's own blog that was also listed, she basically said: (paraphrased)
If you are previously unpubbed, any agent that would bother with you, isn't worth having. She did make a small concession to an obscure possibility that you might be Hemmingway and then it's all good.
So... I wouldn't want to be a member of any club that would have me for a member... right?
Personally, I have some miniscule publishing credits that most, if not all, legitimate agents/editors wouldn't consider worthy of mention... and that might even be the nice way they'd put it. Therefore, I am basically unpublished. Am I crazy for bothering to attempt to find an agent?
Her main theory was, get an offer... then you'll get an agent worthy of being your (or anyone's) rep.
So what's the choice here:
True? Not true? Some seeds of truth? Give it up, if you're looking for seeds go dig in a garden?
In the blog there was a posted response from a well-established editor at a well-recognised company in regards to good/bad agents, and whether they're necessary at all.
Without naming any names, or posting direct quotes, because I don't want to point fingers, and in general I really liked the article, and the editor's own blog that was also listed, she basically said: (paraphrased)
If you are previously unpubbed, any agent that would bother with you, isn't worth having. She did make a small concession to an obscure possibility that you might be Hemmingway and then it's all good.
So... I wouldn't want to be a member of any club that would have me for a member... right?
Personally, I have some miniscule publishing credits that most, if not all, legitimate agents/editors wouldn't consider worthy of mention... and that might even be the nice way they'd put it. Therefore, I am basically unpublished. Am I crazy for bothering to attempt to find an agent?
Her main theory was, get an offer... then you'll get an agent worthy of being your (or anyone's) rep.
So what's the choice here:
True? Not true? Some seeds of truth? Give it up, if you're looking for seeds go dig in a garden?