Let's kick this around a little.
Pros and cons of each?
Opinions?
Who makes more money, novelists or screenwriters?
Ever listen to or read any of the Gurus like Syd Field, John Truby or Blake Snyder or McKee, among others? Their techniques apply just as easily to the screen as they do to page. Anyone agree or disagree?
I think the main drawback to screenwriting is once you sell the script, the studio can do whatever they want with it.
What do you all think?
Most screenwriters and writers make nothing, or very, very little. The top screenwriters and the top novelists both make millions.
The two forms of writing have very, very little in common except for dialogue. The only way there is to tell whether a novelist can write a good screenplay is to have that writer write and sell a screenplay. The only way there is to tell whether a screenwriter can write a good novel is to have that screenwriter write and sell a novel.
At any rate, who makes more money means nothing. Both tend to make a lot, or they make nothing.
Having very few people recognize your name is only a drawback if you write for fame, and not many like fame after it comes. The people who matter, those with checkbooks and very large bank accounts, know your name.
Having other writers and directors change your screenplay can be very bad, or very good. It depends on how well it's done, and whether you want to treat your words like untouchable gold, or whether you want the best possible end product.
Screenwriting and novel writing are simply different worlds that require different talents, and different personality traits. One world is no better than the other, except for individual taste.
And, of course, if you write a novel that gets turned into a movie, you probably have zero control over the script, even if you write it.
Hollywood is just different. There a famous story of Hollywood buy film rights to a novel because they LOVED the title beyond measure. Then they wrote a completely different story to go with the title. And then they changed the title.
But the novelist had still sold film rights, even though the resulting film had nothing at all to do with the novel he wrote.
Money is a poor reason to think about either. You have to do what your talent allows you to do, and live in the world that best fits your personality. I know some extremely happy novelists, some extremely happy screenwriters, and some extremely happy writers who do both.
I know rich and poor. talented and talentless, in both camps.
I do believe in writing for money, but I also believe that the best way to get money from writing is to write whatever it is you most love writing.