Favorite Girl Scout Cookies

Cella · Feb 20, 2010

Yep, that's the question...

I only listed the 3 most popular listed from the Girl Scouts website. Also, in other parts of the world they may have different names.

alleycat · Feb 20, 2010

I don't know what's the favorite, but I do know that little brown-eyed girls selling cookies can turn grown men into mush (yes, me too; her name is Sarah G.). They should be selling Toyotas or furniture!

MattW · Feb 20, 2010

All time favorite is thin mints, but I've eaten my quota over the years. Now my favorites are peanut/oatmeal sandwiches, and lemonade cookies.

I didn't buy any this year - I missed all my usual suppliers.

Perks · Feb 20, 2010

Thin mints are made with crack. Those Girl Scouts looks so sweet and innocent, but they're all playas and thugs.

soapdish · Feb 20, 2010

Samoas. Definitely Samoas. Or as my husband calls them...Samoans. LOL Which I've tried to explain to him aren't nearly as tasty crumbled over ice cream.

Cella · Feb 20, 2010

@ soapy--

Wayne K · Feb 20, 2010

Thin mints, lock thread, everyone go home, nothing to see here.

Cella · Feb 20, 2010

my favorite are samoas but I can eat an entire box of almost any of them in one sitting.

Once I get the taste for one, I can't stop...

Seams · Feb 20, 2010

I'm with Wayne, those mints rock. I consider myself famililess when sharing those is involved

cscarlet · Feb 20, 2010

Cella said:
my favorite are samoas but I can eat an entire box of almost any of them in one sitting.

Once I get the taste for one, I can't stop...

THIS!!!!!!!!

*drool*

Cella · Feb 20, 2010

and who else loves them frozen?! :hooray:

Oh, I do. I'm getting like 12-15 boxes tomorrow!!! I ordered some then my mom gives me all the one she orders.

and now that I'm pregnant, I can eat as many as I want!!! woooooooot!

Jersey Chick · Feb 20, 2010

Samoas.... mmmmmmm....

My daughter's a Girl Scout - we were up to our eyes in Samoas. mmmmmmmmmmm....

soapdish · Feb 20, 2010

Yes, frozen is the way to go!

Shadow_Ferret · Feb 20, 2010

It's a tie for me between the tagalongs and the peanut butter sandwich cookies.

kerry · Feb 20, 2010

Thin mints are my all-time favorite, but tagalongs are pretty close behind! Yum, now I want some.

Elaine Margarett · Feb 20, 2010

Ah, for me it's Tagalongs! Love em, love em, LOVE EM!

It just makes me mad how they keep upping the prices, decreasing the amount of cookies per box and how very little the girl scout troops who sell them get of the profits. When I was the cookie mom for my daughter's troop they made .33 cents out of every $3.50 cent box they sold.

At least the boy scouts get more money from their popcorn sales.

Susie · Feb 20, 2010

My kinda thread, Cella. Don't they still have the oreo-like cookies? Love those.

backslashbaby · Feb 20, 2010

OMG Samoas. I had forgotten the name. I hate you for this thread

Cella · Feb 20, 2010

I would be a Girl Scout again just for guaranteed access to the cookies. Year after year I miss the ordering time because I can't keep up with which niece is in it and which one isn't.

Plus, maybe they'd let me finish some of those merit badges.

(funny derail: I once went on a Boy Scout camping trio with my brother and dad--which is when I got lost in the mountains looking for a bathroom

--and they gave me an honorary merit badge. Really, I think they just had an extra one they didn't feel like finding a place for, but I loved it anyway.

)

writerterri · Feb 20, 2010

All the above!

I make a thinmintsamoapeanutbutter sandwich cookie. I refrain from eating the girl scout though.

They're much too cute.

And they have way too much energy.

Ken · Feb 20, 2010

... quit eating junk, but I do buy a box when the neighborhood GSer's come about each year. The GSA is a good organization for youngsters to be involved in and I'm happy to support it. As to the cookies it's a simple matter to chuck them in the trash when they arrive or bring them to work when I'm working a temp gig.

Cella · Feb 20, 2010

Ken said:
... quit eating junk, but I do buy a box when the neighborhood GSer's come about each year. The GSA is a good organization for youngsters to be involved in and I'm happy to support it. As to the cookies it's a simple matter to chuck them in the trash when they arrive or bring them to work when I'm working a temp gig.

Lavern08 · Feb 20, 2010

I voted other = Trefoils - Lurv me some butter cookies!

Elaine Margarett · Feb 20, 2010

Homemade Tagalongs

My sister-in-law makes homemade Tagalongs using vanilla wafers that she smears with peanut butter and then dips in melted chocolate. Delicious! Just like the real thing.

writerterri · Feb 20, 2010

Cella said:

I second that look.

Favorite Girl Scout Cookies

What is your favorite Girl Scout Cookie?

Thin Mints

Samoas (chocolate, caramel & coconut)

Tagalongs (peanut butter patties w/ chocolate)

Other

Cella

Still around

Company Man

delicate #!&@*#! flower

writing

Cella

Cella

&#9675;

AW = Procrastination.

Cella

Up all night to get Loki

writing

Court Jester

High and Dry

Thanks, special friend for my avi!

~~~~*~~~~

Cella

It's a dorky day!

Cella

Sit Down, and Shut Up!

High and Dry

It's a dorky day!

○

*