Woah. Okay. You've made a few assumptions about me here. In turn I may have made a few about what the poster was trying to say. Let me clear the air.
Is beginner that subjective of a term? I think beginner implies you are learning the basics of a craft, which means you're not yet at a professional level. Basics in writing are fairly well established. Beginner simply means you're 'new' to something. I think the terminology used is where I began to disagree with the poster. (Will explain in a sec.)
This isn't a presentation of fact. This is my opinion. I only think beginning writers should be aware they have a long road ahead of them and not expect instant gratification. I don't feel my opinion is more valid than anyone else's, but I certainly don't mind stating it.
my statements weren't directed at AW users. They're some of the brightest and most well informed writers around, I think. And if not, they quickly become so after joining. AW is a wonderful resource that is proof that writing is all about the labor of love (or is it love of labor?
). Self confidence and self entitlement are quite different things. Confidence is great and I think everyone aught to be confident when pursuing something they're passionate about.
I do think emotion and drive are good. Emotion and drive and foresight are better. I am no prodigy, believe me, but thank you for the cookie. Sweet tooth here.
Also, I consider myself more or less a beginner. I never said anything with the intention of looking down on beginners. I just felt the statement that a beginner is as good as an expert just because they learn the basics is ridiculous. I don't purport to be on that level, and I know I have a long lonely (mostly) road ahead of me like everyone else. I'm okay with it, and I'm realistic about it. I know when I've written something that could be published, technically speaking, and I know when I've written something sub-par.
I don't think it's stupid for a beginner to try. I do think it's wrong to pander false hope that is the equivalent of telling a piano student that's two weeks into lessons they aught to play live, because as long as they know chopsticks they can be as good as Mozart. That's what I thought the thread was getting at. Too often is really hard work, the backbone of any goal, forgotten IMO.
My comment was not a reflection of the site. But I am weary of threads like this, my reasoning already stated.
I will say, I agree with the poster that going back to the basics is important. And forgive me for being harsh; perhaps I read something into the thread that wasn't there.
My previous post was hasty at best.