I'm not going to mention this college lit mag by name, but I will say it is a low-caliber mag so far as quality goes. On all levels--fiction, poetry, photography, all of it is fairly mediocre. This particular mag has really made me disbelieve the notion that "online" pubs are worse than "print" pubs just by nature.
Anyways, I sent in and was rejected several years ago--I wasn't particularly heartbroken or anything; I sent the work in on the last day to submit and it was slightly over the length limit.
But their rejection letter is what got me. Paraphrasing, it said they were sorry, but that there were a large amount of submissions and the rejection wasn't a reflection on my work.
Most of the time, I'd chalk it up as "yeah right, of course it was a reflection on my work. They're just being polite and this needs more polishing."
But in this particular magazine, the (student) judges who decide which works go into the pub also published various stories, poems and pictures in the pub.
So, isn't that essentially self-publishing, and also an ethical issue? I can't see how it isn't, but maybe I'm looking at it wrong. If there're so many submissions why take up valuable space with your own writing? Shouldn't you either be a judge or a submitting artist, not both? What do you think?
Anyways, I sent in and was rejected several years ago--I wasn't particularly heartbroken or anything; I sent the work in on the last day to submit and it was slightly over the length limit.
But their rejection letter is what got me. Paraphrasing, it said they were sorry, but that there were a large amount of submissions and the rejection wasn't a reflection on my work.
Most of the time, I'd chalk it up as "yeah right, of course it was a reflection on my work. They're just being polite and this needs more polishing."
But in this particular magazine, the (student) judges who decide which works go into the pub also published various stories, poems and pictures in the pub.
So, isn't that essentially self-publishing, and also an ethical issue? I can't see how it isn't, but maybe I'm looking at it wrong. If there're so many submissions why take up valuable space with your own writing? Shouldn't you either be a judge or a submitting artist, not both? What do you think?