If so, it shows a definite lack of understanding of the Meyer's books as well as her success as an author.
I read them, I understood them, and I didn't like them, speaking as an aspiring writer.
But, let's take the points, shall we?
1) She had a dream which inspired her to write a novel. Wow. What a horrible way to find inspiration for a story.
2) Have you read the books? If you have read the books then reread them. Her characters are
not cardboard cutouts. I covered this issue in another thread. You can find it here:
Twilight Series What Scarletpeaches said, they are cardboard. Bella stands there, trips, nearly gets run over, and things happen around her. As Tomo so eloquently posted, Edward is 100 years old, he's about as deep as a saucer of milk. Did he learn nothing over that century, a century when the world went from horses and cars to jet planes?
3) She had a plot. Excellent plot. Excellent story. You may want to take another look at it if you didn't see it in the first place. You can not tell a good story without a plot. And she tells a very good story.
Ah, yes, plot. Miserable, self-absorbed girl gets into stupid situations and relies on others to bail her out. Deep stuff, that.
4) I am not sure how using descriptors in one's story equates to rape. It is a very odd metaphor which frankly doesn't fit. It also is vile. I do not understand why I am seeing it used as much as I have lately. Not cute at all, if that was the intention.
5) I read in the forums earlier that she did not try to market Twilight to YA, that that was a decision on part of her agent. What your point insinuates, however, is that the book wouldn't sell if it was marketed to an adult audience. (It also puts down young people, which is irritating to the max.) You might want to go tell that to all those adults who have bought and read the books and are now fans, including those who have started their own online fandom sites.
"You might", you use that a lot, it's a little patronising, please don't do that.
6) Rake in cash. Is that not the ultimate goal of having a book published? I personally can do without the fame if I am making the money to meet my financial goals. Kudos to Meyers for 'raking in the cash'.