Hmm, Rabe: I checked out ICEmpress' link, and they disagree with you...they suggest mild-with-mild, and strong-with-strong in flavors. I can sorta see their pt.
I'm no expert, but wouldn't putting, say, a strong dark chocolate with a mild wine or beer (or cheese) just overpower the milder flavor? Maybe that's why the website suggests pairing like with like?
But now I'm curious and want to try both, and actually pay attention to what I'm tasting. You've got me taste-buds all riled up! *goes down to kitchen*
Her link is wrong. HA!!
No, seriously have you ever done the 'potato chips' and 'ice cream' mix?
Yes? No? If the answer is know HIGH THEE TO THINE SUPERMARKET FOR THE INGREDIENTS!!!!
Seriously though, the idea isn't to mask one flavor with another. It's the 'shocking the system' kind of thing. You chase a strong flavor with the milder one and the tongue is revved up for the bitter so the sweeter flavor is actually intensified. Where you go with the mild, the sweeter side is revved up and suddenly the stronger flavor is intensified. Which is why I don't advocate for a chocolate covered hunk of cheese but chocolate following cheese, or cheese following chocolate.
When you pair mild with mild and strong with strong, you don't get the combative synergestic effect. You get complimentary and they just go 'blah'! The same idea of putting red against a green field, or green against a red field. They are contrasting colors and the one that is lesser seems more vibrant. But if you put blue on blue, they compliment too much and just sort of blend.
But, if you've had ice cream (vanilla usually) with potato chips (the Lays regular or Ruffles kind and of the two, Ruffles are better) then the tongue is activating sweet and salty at the same time and you experience them both in a stronger contrast.
But, go give it a try yourself. You'll find that I'm right.
Cause I'm *always* right - except for when I'm voting.
Rabe...