No Response After Revisions

klow

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jul 13, 2007
Messages
255
Reaction score
11
I probably just need to accept that no response means no interest, but I'd still love to hear from those with more experience.

An agent expressed interest in my non-fiction proposal. She wrote a fairly detailed email to me with ideas for expanding my two sample chapters and said that if I was open to making revisions she'd like to see them. I sent revisions and received an email back from her that she was looking forward to reading the material. This was at the beginning of Sept.

Six weeks went by and I didn't hear anything, so I sent a short email just to check in. I never got a response. It has now been over three months since I sent the revisions. Is it hopeless?

I probably should be sending out queries, but I would love to work with this particular agent...

Any advice or words or wisdom.
 

ZeroMan

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Aug 5, 2008
Messages
79
Reaction score
1
Location
Texas
As another person on this board said to me - Never stop sending out queries.

I had much the same experience. With my first round of queries, only one agent responded. He asked for a proposal which I promptly sent. Then I received another e-mail a few days later asking for some revisions to the proposal. I sent those revisions and got an e-mail back saying "this looks fine to me, let me talk to my partners."

A short time later I got a call from him asking to clarify a few details. He ended the call by saying we'd "touch base in a few days" and sent me his agency contract just for me to "look over". You might imagine I thought I was in pretty good shape and didn't query anyone else at that point.

then... nothing.

A few weeks later I sent a nice e-mail to "make sure he wasn't waiting on anything else from me." No response.

I finally started sending queries to other agents, but after two months I sent the first agent another e-mail basically asking if there was something that I needed to be aware of, something that changed him mind about representing me.

Again...no response.

I'm perfectly aware that they are busy (aren't we all), but many agents seem to have a peculiar sense of civility. It's a shame, too. Because, like you... I really wanted to work with this first agent. He was really nice.

Initially.
 

CrankItTo11

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Nov 14, 2006
Messages
144
Reaction score
16
Location
North of Nowhere
It doesn't hurt to check in - but since you recently sent her a follow-up e-mail, I'd wait. Maybe check in one more time after the new year. The holidays can be a tough time of year to get attention.

I had an agent that requested revisions to my novel. Three months later, I sent her the new manuscript that was revised based on her suggestions (all great suggestions). Two weeks later I had a form rejection. OUCH.

I hope your agent requested revisions story has a happier ending. It sounds like she was really interested! Agents (at least the good ones) spend much more time working with their current clients rather than obtaining new ones. She could very likely have her hands full right now. Three months isn't outrageous... it can just feel outrageous when you are checking your inbox every five minutes. :)

Hang in there and good luck!
 

Danthia

Try contacting her again. E-mails go astray all the time. Send a letter if you're worried e-mail isn't getting through. She also could have been away for some reason, or on a busy conference schedule, preparing for Frankfurt, maternity leave, who knows.

If she has a website or blog, try there to see if there's any news on her.
 

klow

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jul 13, 2007
Messages
255
Reaction score
11
Thank you everyone!! :)
 

qwerty

exiled Brit
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Mar 9, 2007
Messages
1,076
Reaction score
222
Location
Burgundy
I wouldn't say it's necessarily hopeless, but if an agent asks for revisions, I'd say it would be courteous of him/her to respond to those revisions.

My agent phoned to ask if I would be prepared to carry out some revision he wanted to suggest. Obviously I said I would, and I did. Less than a week after I subbed the revised ms he offered representation.

However much you want to work with a particular agent, it has to be one that has time to fit you and your work into their schedule - however busy they are. Keeping you hanging around is not fair when you could be subbing elsewhere.

By all means wait and see what this agent has to say - after you've chased up again - but no harm in subbing elsewhere in the meantime.
 

scope

Commonsensical Maverick
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Mar 30, 2008
Messages
2,763
Reaction score
251
Location
New York
Get on the query bandwagon immediately!

As for the agent who requested revisions, I'd send another email and ask what's up. However, I wouldn't expect much of a reply (hope I'm wrong).