So, Lion King, Wicked, Phantom, Book of Mormon, and... well, here it gets complicated, 'cause I don't know what will still be playing, or have been revived, when we go. You might like Rain, 'cause it's a Beatles tribute, but at the same time it's people dressed up singing Beatles songs, so you might not.
We have to shop on Canal Street, because it is the cheapest and funnest way of getting 90% useless junk and 10% perfect cosplay accessories that you will wear forever more. If possible, Hard Rock Café or Planet Hollywood would be fantastic. Also Ellen's Stardust Diner, where aspiring Broadway stars work as singing waiters, at least one vendor dog/central park lunch, and maybe a Five Guys lunch. Also M&M World, and a stop into Nintendo World to look at all their old cool stuff and decide to buy a bag or T-shirt only to change your mind minutes later and then regret that.
And shopping XD