Yikes, that is one scary ass couch!
I know, I know. It is early and it is just one opinion. I thought I would have more time before all the doom and gloom started in. I thought I had built up a thicker skin than this. Silly. I had hoped the previous failed querying attempt would make this round of Rs roll off of me.
I don't agree with agent's comments, but they caught me off guard. I expect form, the "didn't fall in love with it" type stuff. Instead I got a rambling explanation detailing the ways my idea is great but I haven't spent enough time developing it. How my chapters are too short. (!) I wouldn't revise based on it. But it leaves me feeling a little nauseous. It reminds me of that "doesn't live up to full potential" comment on a report card.
So, that will teach me to lament the form reply, that I can brush aside!