Dee - Class Action Lawsuit
Thought all of you would enjoy this. Unfortunately, I messed up my html before posting it on the PW MB.
BTW, James, is what you’re saying really a possibility? Could PA be in copyright violation?
If anyone does find an attorney, let me know? I’d like in on the Class Action Suit.
<hr />
Submitted by: Tim Johnson (
[email protected])
12/16/2004 4:20:38 PM PT
Location: Wauchula, Florida
Occupation: Author
Carl: Kat and others, excuse me but I fail to see any evil or false claims here.
Tim: My work was published (excuse me, deceptively stolen) by PublishAmerica in June of 2003. Here’s the info:
Author: Tim Johnson
Book: Twisted oak: Eyes of Discernment
ISBN: 1-59286-679-4
Pages: 252
I did research on Publish America prior to submitting my manuscript to them. I checked with the BBB in 2002, and searched other places on the Internet to see if PA was legit, but found nothing. I scrutinized their Web site for quite a while before submitting my work to them. They claimed that the majority of their books could be found in physical brick & mortar stores. Unfortunately, they lied. Two years have gone by and I still haven’t found a single PA book in any bookstore except for when I had my first—and only, I might add—signing at the local bookstore in my hometown.
(Once more) Carl: Kat and others, excuse me but I fail to see any evil or false claims here.
Tim: Publish America lied back then, and they still lie today. What happens to someone when they lie to a judge that wants the whole truth and nothing but the truth?
Carl: If you and those who had books published via PA don't like the job they have done. Simply ask for your rights back or wait for the contract to end and place the book somewhere else.
Tim: PublishAmerica didn’t do their job as far as I’m concerned. I did the plotting, I did the writing (which took 7 years at least), I worked on the interior art (including the map and photos), and I designed the book’s front and back cover. Here’s the work PA did: They transformed the format of my work with the click of a button, and then printed it. Wow, how tedious. I suppose PA deserves a standing ovation.
(Once more) Carl: If you and those who had books published via PA don't like the job they have done. Simply ask for your rights back or wait for the contract to end and place the book somewhere else.
Tim: I’ve asked…many times, in fact. But they provoked me one too many times, and this is the result: another angry author joining hundreds more in exposing PublishAmerica for what it really is.
Carl: What have any of you lost?
Tim: I lost at least 7 years. Some have lost their entire life, especially if they signed the old contract.
Carl: You guys make it sound like other publishers were breaking down your door trying to sign you and you opt for PA instead. Kat, never believe hype or ads? Always investigate. But really what is there to investigate you are either publish by a major or you're not. The major is the route to go even if you are midlist but we all know that they reject most manuscripts and queries they receive. The only other options are presses like PA, Winterwolf (just an example) and other more known small houses. The point is all of the "other" is practically the same. The author will still have to be the point man in promo and sales will still be dismal. If you get an advance from these "others" chances are you'll never see a royalty check. But, this is true even with the majors. You people still fail to understand that being author SUCKS for everybody but a small percentage of chosen people who get fabulous promotion. That Kat is the reality of the situation. All this other bullcrap about editing, don't market, books not in bookstores (name a house outside of a major entity in bookstores to any great degree?), rude to me, etc. is all B.S. and sour grapes.
Tim: No comment. All of that was garbage, undeserving of a comment.
Carl: The other point is most of the whiners and complainers here will be unhappy whoever they're with cause nobody is ever going to put any real money behind any of your projects. Why should they when virtually none of you are willing to invest in yourselfs and those of you who do get upset when the investment doesn't pan out.
Tim: What about J.K. Rowling? She was an unknown until revealing her Harry Potter masterpiece. And she obviously didn’t have any money to start with. In fact, if my memory serves me correctly, she was living on welfare due to circumstances beyond her control before becoming famous. Did that stop a major publisher from seeing merit in her work? No. They still took the chance, and I’m sure they’re glad they did.
Carl: You people are the definitive definition of "LOSERS." Personally, I wouldn't contract with any of you to even pick up my trash.
Tim: And I’m certain that no one would even consider the offer.
Carl: So don't send me no damn queries...and I remember names.
Tim: Thanks for the warning, Willem…uh, I mean, Carl. I don’t believe that any of us ex-PA authors would even consider that, either. I’m sure I vouch for my fellow writers when I say, “We’ve all had our fill of PublishAmerica.”
<hr />