Momentomori, here are the answers to your questions.
Not sure why I even respond to such negative group of writers with a condescending attitude toward other writers but I will, as I think it's important to shed some light on the situation.
And we appreciate that. All we've done here is ask questions.
I'm not trying to sell you anything nor do I think Kim did and with all honesty I much prefer if you didn't join the writers out website as there is no room for such negative "vibe" on their site as it's been nothing but a wonderful outlet for me and many of my friends.
Just out of curiosity, is whether or not we join up to you? I'm just confused by you telling us you'd rather we not join; that makes it sound like our joining would have some effect on you, or as if you have a say in our possible membership(s).
1. My friend has received an email from writersout as a result of signing up on their newsletter board. WHY did my friend sign up to receive their newsletter??? My friend has signed up before they launch their site apparently after reading an article about them which interviewed the Co-founders (it was a positive article and so I don't think there's anything in it for you).
I've only found one interview with the founder of the site, Inbal Gould; the name of the co-founder isn't mentioned anywhere. That interview is
here on the Writers Out site, as well as being cross-posted to several other places.
There was also a mention of them in a
Fiscaltimes.com article about people working for free, but I didn't see any actual quotes from either founder in it and their names are not given; the actual text concerning the site is on page three of the article, and reads in its entirety:
WritersOut.com, launching next month, will ask both new and established writers to publish and share their work on the site gratis, ideally building an audience and enough page views to appeal to advertisers down the road.
So I guess your friend saw the mention in Fiscal Times? Because the other interview is only a few weeks old.
I took your advice, though, and used Google to do some research (thanks for the tip)! I discovered that
Googling founder Inbal Gould turns up what ends up being only a page and a half of hits (the initial search shows four pages, but most of them are similar and so are omitted on page two). Indeed, all of those hits relate to the interview posted on Writers Out. I find no indication of any publishing experience.
WritersOut does have a
Twitter account, as well as a
Facebook fan page. Oh, now here's something; the Facebook page links to
an article in an online media magazine about the site's investor, Joshua Gould, who just happens to share the same last name with Inbal--in fact, apparently the Goulds own a large company providing "language services," (translations) and have been very successful, which, great. It would seem that there is some money behind the operation--WritersOut is apparently part of the business--and they seem like decent enough people (although they've apparently made some enemies; there are a few Twitter accounts out there that don't like them much, but that looked to me like somebody's rather childish personal vendetta so I'm not going to dignify them with links), but I'm still not seeing experience with publishing.
Mr. Gould claims in the interview that the site will be "bigger than Myspace" (presumably when it was big, and not essentially bankrupt as it is now) and says they have connections with Oprah's book club and that "Sarah Palin's team is on board."
The problem, of course, is that books aren't sold the same way translation/language services are, and MySpace became successful not because it was a place for sellers to interact with buyers but because it was initially a place where friends could stay in touch with friends.
2. What's good about the site??? Too many things to list but will try in order to answer Momentomori's question. It's a professional network for writers which allows me to upload my portfolio of work, view statistic, sell and share with all my other networks by inviting them in to connect on one platform rather than jump from my LinkedIn, FB and other only to forward readers to my "other" profile. This place is for writers. I can also post my widget on my FB page and sell my books directly on FB. The fact that all of you are so angry about such a positive cause is what really surprise me simply because as writers, someone has created a place for us to network with each and our audience.
Thank you for answering this question, which Kimstar wouldn't do. And we're not angry; why would we be?
If I'm understanding this correctly, then, from your response and Mr. Gould's comments in the interview I linked to, the idea is that writers can network with each other, and each have a page where they can sell their self-published work from (because generally only self-published or vanity-published authors can sell their books directly off their websites)? And they can automatically send buy links to their non-WritersOut friends through email and by using the Facebook widget the site provides?
So it's just like you have a Facebook page, only on a Facebook specifically for writers. Is that correct?
But why are readers there? My readers connect with me/interact with me through my website and blog, through Twitter, through Facebook, etc. I can't really see them taking the time to register on another site to say hello or have a chat with me when I'm already accessible elsewhere, and I can't see them signing up for a site like this just in case they might find a new writer. Honestly, readers like to interact with writers, sure, but when they're looking for new writers to read they generally talk to other readers, rather than registering on a writers' site and wandering around looking for stuff to read.
I have a website/blog/Twitter account/Facebook page specifically in order to publicize my books and interact with my readers; why do I then need to sign up for WritersOut to interact with other writers? Especially since most of my friends are writers and I interact with them all the time, too, on the aforementioned sites and on forums like this and through email, of course, and in person when we have the chance?
So who is the "audience" you're connecting with there? Because, sadly, I have to tell you that what usually happens when you have groups of authors but no readers on a site to sell books, you end up with lots of talk about buying each others' books/trading reviews/trading fairly useless "promo" tips like putting flyers in the envelopes when you pay your bills, and very few books actually being sold.
The simple fact that there are writers about isn't in itself a draw for readers. It never has been. Specific writers, sure, that can be. But writers in general, especially (sorry, but it's true) self-published writers who are there to try to promote their books...readers tend to run from that.
3. "Google" is a great search tool, you should check it out!
As you can see, I did! I also found that your WritersOut Profile shows zero books sold, at least from what I can tell since your profile is set to "private." I'm kind of confused about that; how is it possible for you to find readers when they can't see information about you or your work?
You're
listed as a Blogger on the WritersOut site, but Google didn't turn up any blogs for that name (none that seemed to fit, anyway, unless you're only seventeen years old, but that blogger didn't sound like you). So is the purpose of being there to publicize your blog? Or are you just having fun chatting about writing with your friends--which is of course fine, and it's great that you're enjoying yourself.
I have read their T&C after reading the heated comments on this forum and their T&C is no different than Facebook or any other network. It is free and if they will ever decide to change their mind, they will let you know.
Again, the only heated comments on that subject came from Kimstar.
My personal feelings are that it's free and was created for us the writers, it provides a great service so take it or leave it, it's up to you but do yourself a (big) favor, stop with all the hate messages.
And "take it or leave it" is fine advice, but the purpose of this forum is to provide information and opinions to help writers decide which of those options they'll take when it comes to any given publisher/agent/service.
No one, absolutely no one, here is posting "hate messages," and if we were I fail to see how stopping them would be doing ourselves a "favor." That sounds like a threat; what are you threatening us with? What will happen if we don't stop?
As Momento Mori so eloquently said:
It's not condescending to ask legitimate questions and answering them goes to establishing your credibility as a poster given that you're new to the forum.
The purpose of this Forum is to raise potential issues with publishers, agents etc so that people can make an informed decision. Newbie posters who drive by with an "OMG this site is so kewl and u r all meen for saying bad things!!!" carry little weight with the posters here and usually serve to damage reputation rather than restore it.
Given the Kimstar sockpuppetry and the general level of reading comprehension/writing skill displayed by some of the WritersOut defenders in this thread and on the WritersOut site itself, I had a pretty lousy impression of them; the info I found on Google made me see this more as a well-intentioned attempt to create a new social networking site, although I'm still disturbed by the T&C and the rather pricey "self-publishing" packages. It's a shame we didn't get that info up front, instead of generic comments about meanies.
Also as Momento said:
Given that you're apparently happy to answer questions (for which I thank you), you missed these 2, which I draw your attention to again:
- Are you selling your work over the site and if so, how many copies are you selling?
- Are you at all concerned by the fact that the site reserves the right to start charging for its use in the future?
Okay so how does that help sales? How many professional writers are on the site (or are you defining "professional" as someone who merely uses the site to sell work)?
Facebook doesn't operate as a display site for published work.
Which other networks do you think operate similar Ts and Cs?
It's currently free but the site reserves the right to charge in the future. This is a point that I know I've made several times and I'm still interested in knowing how and why you're comfortable with it.
As regards the "hate messages", given that there haven't been any I don't see what there is to stop. If you really want to support the site you apparently enjoy, then you'd be better off dropping the snarky, passive-aggressive attitude because (a) it's not working for you and (b) it just makes people think that writersout has stuff to hide.
One final point to note, I checked out the ownership details for writersout.com and it goes through to an address in Madeira, Portugal. When you search that address on Google (which is a great search tool by the way - we should all try it) it seems to be linked to a number of other websites, all of which have had scam queries raised about them. I will make a point of saying that I'm not seeing anything on writersout to indicate that it's a scam, but it would make me reluctant to give them my credit card details or any details that could be used to steal my identity.
MM
Thanks again for answering questions, Hanna.