I'm still on a search for an agent, and with all the newbies, scammers and snobs I've crossed off my list, this one put me over the edge. Perhaps because my blood's already angried up this afternoon, I just sent this email (NOT from the address I use for writing projects):
I'm doing some research on some agencies and stumbled across your web site. While I realize you're no longer seeking submissions, I nevertheless feel compelled, as a writer and advocate for writers, to express my concern regarding the page you keep on livejournal.com listing rejected submissions (
http://barnardagency.livejournal.com/28251.html).
Submitting to an agency can be a leap of faith. Writing is a solitary craft, and sending it to an agent can be a big step. Listing the titles you've rejected as an agent betrays the trust a writer places in you when sending a query or manuscript. It can make the rejection letter, already a devastating moment in beginning writers' lives, a tool of public scorn, one that could potentially make a writer choose to toss a manuscript in the wastebasket or the bottom of a desk drawer rather than rewrite and soldier on. And what of the writers who've made simultaneous submissions?
Of greater importance is the image it expresses to professional writers and other agents. No existing or folded agency that I've ever encountered engages in such a practice. It displays a lack of understanding of the industry, one that a writer with minimal experience will recognize as a red flag; one that a fellow agent will see as an attempt to say "don't waste your time" to colleagues. Was posting this list a means of demonstrating that you're the "real deal"? If so, that's usually done by listing books you've actually sold, which is, at the end of the day, the truest measure of an agent's worth.
While I realize you've had a "change of direction," leaving this list posted is nevertheless a tacky - and potentially damaging - legacy for your stint as a literary agent.
Sincerely,
A Concerned Writer and Editor