Passenger, by Alexandra Bracken. Note to self: make sure your characters match the ages you've given them.
OK, I read some romance. I read a lot of YA. This is the second book I've picked up that annoyed me because the author (who is otherwise a competent writer) made the characters 17 then wrote them like you'd write an older romance novel. We are supposed to believe in this book where the protagonist has been transported back to the 1700s and is on a pirate ship, that a fair number of the
officers on the ship are only 18-19ish. No, just no. And I'm sorry, but making a character 17 when they are written like you'd write a slightly older character doesn't help your book. The readers will not be fooled.
When you write a character they have to match the age you give them. You can have your character be a prodigy and still be young. I think
Ender's Game managed that well. Every YA book doesn't have to be about prom and high school.
Daughter of Smoke and Bone was excellent. The Young Elites fit their ages well, no high school, no prom. But
The Winner's Curse series also didn't read like 17 and 19 year old characters. That one read older as well.
Yep, it's a skill to write a character that fits the age you give them. Romance masquerading as YA, not fooling anyone. It's a decent Romance novel, why the need to shoehorn it into a genre it doesn't belong in?
Thank you for listening.