Picking up again after a year of inactivity

Byeka

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Aug 16, 2017
Messages
104
Reaction score
36
Location
Canada
New here and saw this section of the forum. Figured I might as well share my tale.

I finished writing my book a few years ago, 2014 I think. I spent at least the next 1-2 years editing it, getting beta readers, feedback, and applying more edits. The overall concensus was that the story was enjoyable and fun to read.

Then came the tricky part, learning how to write a query letter. I read through the entire Queryshark archives, not missing a single one. I took 27 pages of notes, wrote several iterations of my own query letter, got feedback, made edits, until I had something that I was decently happy with. Then, I started querying agents. Agent, after agent, after agent. And not one single request came for a full or even a partial. I got used to either form rejection letters or not hearing anything back at all. It was extremely disheartening. I don't remember how many I queried but what a blow to the ego.

Then, almost exactly one year ago, I took a different approach. Tired of emailing nameless faces, I attended Toronto Writing Workshop and paid to attend a session where I would meet one-on-one with literary agents and pitch them my story in person. This was far better. One of the agents I met with loved my pitch and asked me to email her my full story. I was extremely excited, I waited patiently, dying to hear something back. And then it happened... about a month later I got an email from her, a Standard. Form. Rejection. Letter. No elaboration, no different than the many standard form rejection letters I had received from the blank faces online.

It killed my motivation. I felt useless. Hopeless. Absolutely dead inside. I shelved my entire story, query letter, and put it all aside.

Now for the first time since then, I'm resurfacing. I've written a brand new query letter and am hoping to make enough of a contribution here that I can earn a critique.

I have a good story to tell. I know I do. And I'm determined to see it published one way or another.

I've found one hybrid-publisher who wants to publish my story. However, as I said they are a "hybrid" publisher where the author pays for everything, and it doesn't get distributed into actual bookstores. I don't feel too great about this and in a thread I made on reddit asking for opinions on the matter, everyone advised against it. Oddly enough, I checked and they're on the AW index, not listed as a 'scam' or stay-away from or anything like that.
 
Last edited:

novicewriter

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Aug 16, 2017
Messages
293
Reaction score
48
Hello, fellow new member! I just wanted to offer my condolences, as I've been having the same, constant rejection for my short story when submitting it to literary magazines. I thought that, since a few judges liked it enough to longlist it for a writing contest, and commented that all of the longlisted stories were quality enough to win other writing contests or be published it literary magazines, that that meant that other literary editors would like it, too, and publish it. But, my best guess is that the editors might be thinking that it's not long enough, or that it may be too dark of a subject for what they want to publish, even though it ends on a good note.

Are you able to self-publish your book?
 
Last edited:

Byeka

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Aug 16, 2017
Messages
104
Reaction score
36
Location
Canada
Dang, that sucks as well!

I actually started looking down that route recently and it's what led to me finding the hybrid publisher I mentioned at the end of my post, as the recommendation for them came from a freelance editor.

After receiving their terrifying quote for editing, design, etc., I thought maybe I can give traditional publishing another shot as it's honestly where I'd prefer to be anyway. I've completely overhauled my query letter so eventually I will be hoping to get it critiqued here before I go for another round of querying agents.
 

spikeman4444

The snozberrys taste lke snozberrys
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Oct 22, 2009
Messages
907
Reaction score
77
Location
anytown, USA
You should spend some time in the query hell forum, as well as SYW. You'll need to reach 50 posts I believe before they let you post your work though.

My advice, query in stages. Query 4-8 agents and wait a month to hear back from them. Then send another batch. If you're not getting requests for partials, that means your query needs fixing. I'd also suggest you don't close the door on attending workshops and conferences in the future, as that's how I found my eventual agent...even though the manuscript I pitched to her at the conference was not the one she signed me for.
 

Harlequin

Eat books, not brains!
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Nov 21, 2010
Messages
4,584
Reaction score
1,412
Location
The land from whence the shadows fall
Website
www.sunyidean.com
I've found one hybrid-publisher who wants to publish my story. However, as I said they are a "hybrid" publisher where the author pays for everything, and it doesn't get distributed into actual bookstores.


They may not be currently listed as a scam, but that sounds an awful like a vanity press--I would stay away and yes, consider QLH and/or self pub over a hybrid or vanity!
 

Byeka

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Aug 16, 2017
Messages
104
Reaction score
36
Location
Canada
@spikeman4444 - Exactly what I intend to do once I've sufficiently contributed. I'm actually curious what people will think about my new query letter as it's quite different than any of my previous versions. Right now, sadly, having an agent take interest in your work feels like the kind of thing that's only possible of happening to somebody else. I've been keeping my eyes open for more writing workshops in my area though.

@Harlequin - yeah that's my thoughts too. I already emailed them back and told them I'm going to keep looking into traditional publication. I don't want to pay thousands of dollars to get my book published, unless I go the self-publishing route and paying that much money is entirely my choice.