Hello everyone.
Sorry about the second thread in this section, but I came to the conclusion that the current WIP that I have been working on for the last week has too many similarities to an already popularized book and feel as though I probably can't continue with it.
With that being said, it WAS a WIP I started working on due to the fact that the one that I was most passionate about started to give me an uneasy feeling that it wasn't diverse enough. So I'm hoping that this is the correct place to put something like this (or the POC section, not sure).
Essentially, this story is about a girl who lost her father a decade ago and hasn't been seen since. She used to live in Galway, Ireland with them until her father disappeared and her mother and her moved to Boston, Massachusetts to be in a community in the U.S. that made them feel safe. She has felt like an outsider her entire life in spite of that due to her father's absence. She has a boyfriend who has "medical issues" that has turned his hair white and his skin pale and his eyes an iridescent blue. She later finds out it's not a medical condition at all, it is due to the fact that he's half dead and has the spirit of a banshee living in him due to his own mother's death. She later finds out that she is the heir to the throne of Ireland and the Otherworld, her father having left due to the fact that a Druid had gone rogue and accepted the dark magics in an effort to take out the King and the other three royal members. More Irish mythology is involved in this but it's just a short summary.
Now, my question regarding this is that I stopped writing it due to the fact that I was worried I didn't have enough diversity in it. The question of diversity and what it encompasses isn't in question, but rather the perception of what diversity is. Because in my story, I have LGBTQ+ characters as well as disabled characters. The problem I'm running into is the ethnicity diversity. I went to look up the demographics of both Galway, Ireland and Boston, Massachusetts, and both places have over 80% white people. I didn't want to feel disingenuous to the story and the culture I'm writing about (a culture that I'm a part of and feel passionately for) but I also am EXTREMELY aware of the necessity of diversity in YA fiction especially. My first novel is full of ethnic diversity but I'm running into a road block of having to write about a culture that is predominantly white.
One of the characters in the story is a black girl who I was planning on having be a bigger presence in the second book of the series, but currently only serves as the MC's best friend who essentially attempts to work through the MC's anxieties and eventually pushes her to the brink that causes the big turning point of my MC realizing that something is just not right. Other than that, she doesn't have a huge impact on the first part of the story.
The question, in short form, is how to do I combat this, and if so, can ethnic diversity be nixed as long as other diverse groups are represented? I don't want to have to do that, but it's this guilty part of my brain that's telling me that this story shouldn't be written if it's not going to help the industry in a place where it needs it most.
All the help would be appreciated. I'm hoping I can overcome this worry. Thank you to all in advance for any advice.
Sorry about the second thread in this section, but I came to the conclusion that the current WIP that I have been working on for the last week has too many similarities to an already popularized book and feel as though I probably can't continue with it.
With that being said, it WAS a WIP I started working on due to the fact that the one that I was most passionate about started to give me an uneasy feeling that it wasn't diverse enough. So I'm hoping that this is the correct place to put something like this (or the POC section, not sure).
Essentially, this story is about a girl who lost her father a decade ago and hasn't been seen since. She used to live in Galway, Ireland with them until her father disappeared and her mother and her moved to Boston, Massachusetts to be in a community in the U.S. that made them feel safe. She has felt like an outsider her entire life in spite of that due to her father's absence. She has a boyfriend who has "medical issues" that has turned his hair white and his skin pale and his eyes an iridescent blue. She later finds out it's not a medical condition at all, it is due to the fact that he's half dead and has the spirit of a banshee living in him due to his own mother's death. She later finds out that she is the heir to the throne of Ireland and the Otherworld, her father having left due to the fact that a Druid had gone rogue and accepted the dark magics in an effort to take out the King and the other three royal members. More Irish mythology is involved in this but it's just a short summary.
Now, my question regarding this is that I stopped writing it due to the fact that I was worried I didn't have enough diversity in it. The question of diversity and what it encompasses isn't in question, but rather the perception of what diversity is. Because in my story, I have LGBTQ+ characters as well as disabled characters. The problem I'm running into is the ethnicity diversity. I went to look up the demographics of both Galway, Ireland and Boston, Massachusetts, and both places have over 80% white people. I didn't want to feel disingenuous to the story and the culture I'm writing about (a culture that I'm a part of and feel passionately for) but I also am EXTREMELY aware of the necessity of diversity in YA fiction especially. My first novel is full of ethnic diversity but I'm running into a road block of having to write about a culture that is predominantly white.
One of the characters in the story is a black girl who I was planning on having be a bigger presence in the second book of the series, but currently only serves as the MC's best friend who essentially attempts to work through the MC's anxieties and eventually pushes her to the brink that causes the big turning point of my MC realizing that something is just not right. Other than that, she doesn't have a huge impact on the first part of the story.
The question, in short form, is how to do I combat this, and if so, can ethnic diversity be nixed as long as other diverse groups are represented? I don't want to have to do that, but it's this guilty part of my brain that's telling me that this story shouldn't be written if it's not going to help the industry in a place where it needs it most.
All the help would be appreciated. I'm hoping I can overcome this worry. Thank you to all in advance for any advice.