Thanks everyone! I know not everyone agrees on which they like best, but that's part of the fun! Every single comment is giving me good things to think about. I know I've got a little more tinkering to do, but I feel I'm getting close!
Cmhbob- I think when I toned down the sky I accidentally lightened the edges. Thanks for the heads up, I like the darker too!
Cindyt- Thanks!
Curlz- I still have some tinkering to do with the title font. I liked the first 'Wyrd" as well, but I did not like the two different fonts, and that font had a sucky "H." I'll try for one a little more like that and a little less "Goosebumps." And it is a more lighthearted read, though it's a mystery. My writing style is more Buffy than Nosferatu. I think the tag is doing it's job.
MysterySpot- I liked the icy blue on the author name as well, but I think the majority did not.
Darien, I am a rank amateur at photoshop, lol. That moon is a filled in circle with some texture thrown over it. I've got some other tinkering to do, so I'll play with making it bigger. The other suggestions might be beyond me, but I'll look into blur on the drop shadow.