The AW Amazon Store
Buy books by AWers

 

Welcome to the AbsoluteWrite Water Cooler! Please read The Newbie Guide To Absolute Write

Page 26 of 26 FirstFirst ... 1620212223242526
Results 626 to 632 of 632

Thread: [Critique Game] Post The First Three Sentences of your Short Story

  1. #626
    practical experience, FTW sockycat's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2016
    Location
    Michigan
    Posts
    297
    Quote Originally Posted by tiddlywinks View Post
    First, I love your title. I have no idea what it means, but you'd catch my eye with that alone.

    I think you need to dig a little deeper into the meat here in order to set the hook for your story. There's a cool concept in here, but it's kinda buried under ok vague. The writing's sound. Just needs a little more...something.

    Sorry, that's all I got.
    Hahaha, thank you! I work full-time for a nonprofit dedicated to preserving and developing low-income housing, and as a result, we run into a LOT of Nimbyism (the "not in my backyard" people)

    Basically, the premise is that Earth is no longer inhabitable, and humans need somewhere else to go. It's a story about a bunch of aliens saying the same stereotypical nymbism bullshit that I hear people say about low-income members of the community. So I just changed NIMBY to NOMP-- Not On My Planet!

    Thank you for the feedback!! I'll try to find a different word for that 1st line
    "Seashells", Aphelion, May 2017

  2. #627
    Exhausted Pidgeon...Pigeon?...bah! tiddlywinks's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2014
    Location
    Sailing Stormy Seas in Search of Pirates
    Posts
    7,438
    Ok, now that is a clever title. I lika!
    Loves to tell stories. Finds editing a necessary evil. No longer fueled by coffee (again).
    ------------

    "Glitter Bugs" - humorous scifi short (subbing)
    Blood Rose, Book 1 - Updated Chapter 1 of Pirate Fantasy (drafting)
    Summer's Sword - PNR, Chapter 1 (polishing) - Query in progress in QLH
    Hopefully Ever After - UF romance, Chapter 1 (querying)

    "Tears of Ink" Blog |
    #tweets (@WittEWrites) | Pinterest plot bunnies

  3. #628
    figuring it all out sublunam's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2017
    Location
    Los Angeles, CA
    Posts
    64
    Quote Originally Posted by sockycat View Post
    The trouble started when the spokesman for ICRML—the Intergalactic Council for Resettlement of Misplaced Lifeforms—turned to the assembly and asked “Now, are there any opposed to the humankind resettlement plan?”

    Objections exploded throughout the room.

    Representatives and community members from nearly thirty planets had gathered, some lounging in the mediocre metal chairs that had been stuffed into the black-tiled room, others standing shoulder to fin.
    Sockycat, I love this premise. I do think you need to do a bit of paring down here, though. The sentences feel a little too densely packed with information for the opening hook. Here are some suggested changes:

    The spokesman for the Intergalactic Council turned to the assembly and asked “Now, are there any opposed to the resettlement plan?” That was when the trouble started. Representatives from nearly thirty planets had gathered--some seated in the metal chairs crammed into the black-tiled room, others standing shoulder to fin--and objections exploded throughout the room.

    I've taken out what I think you might consider to be key information, and so I assume you won't like all of the suggested changes, but I want to put some of them out there. The council name I think you could include in paragraph two, together with the information that the resettlement is going to be of human beings. But I assume if we're halfway through proceedings, there would be no need to refer directly to the species being resettled. In general, I've left your wording as is (just shuffled around), just changing "lounging" to "seated," because "lounging" seemed to be the wrong verb for a bunch of creatures explosively objecting.

    I hope this helps! And I look forward to reading more!
    jlw
    https://sublunam.wordpress.com

    "If my life wasn't funny it would just be true, and that is unacceptable."
    -- Carrie Fisher

  4. #629
    practical experience, FTW sockycat's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2016
    Location
    Michigan
    Posts
    297
    Thanks for the feedback everyone, it's much appreciated !
    "Seashells", Aphelion, May 2017

  5. #630
    practical experience, FTW sockycat's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2016
    Location
    Michigan
    Posts
    297
    Alright, I tried to rework the first three sentences to be less info dump-y so that they can be more engaging. Some of the info that was bogging down the original first three was reworked into later sentences and feels more organic, so I appreciate everyone's feedback on that matter!

    THE NOMPERS Revision 2:

    The trouble started when the spokesman tapped a cracked claw against the desk and said, “We will be taking questions now.”
    Representatives and community members from nearly thirty planets cried out in unison. Some leaped from their chairs, and others slithered up the black tiled walls.
    "Seashells", Aphelion, May 2017

  6. #631
    practical experience, FTW Denevius's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2016
    Location
    Seoul
    Posts
    649
    The trouble started when the spokesman tapped a cracked claw against the desk and said, “We will be taking questions now.”
    Representatives and community members from nearly thirty planets cried out in unison. Some leaped from their chairs, and others slithered up the black tiled walls.
    I think your first version slipped by me, and I didn't comment on it. Examining just the first lines of each version:

    1) The trouble started when the spokesman for ICRML—the Intergalactic Council for Resettlement of Misplaced Lifeforms—turned to the assembly and asked “Now, are there any opposed to the humankind resettlement plan?”

    2) The trouble started when the spokesman tapped a cracked claw against the desk and said, “We will be taking questions now.”

    To me, it's clear that the first line of version 1 is far more interesting. In that one, we have specificity: the ICRML, and a clear plot point to jump off with.

    The second version's first line is a general figure holding something that seems a little silly opening the the narrative up with dialog that I've heard many, many times before.

    And the description of aliens in both versions:

    1) Representatives and community members from nearly thirty planets had gathered, some lounging in the mediocre metal chairs that had been stuffed into the black-tiled room, others standing shoulder to fin.

    2) Some leaped from their chairs, and others slithered up the black tiled walls.

    One does a nice job of implying haste while giving a memorable image of the black tiled room and metal chairs.

    The other, again, just seems a little silly to me, like it's supposed to be a joke.

    So obviously I prefer the first version, and feel this is a step backward. Personally, I don't find the first version to be infodumpy. You were introducing a character, and you said who the character was. The ICRML. To me, there's nothing telly about that that should be avoided, as you then continue right into the present moment situation: the resettlement of the human race.
    INFECTIOUS (Now available in the May 2017, Issue 54 in Expanded Horizons)
    WHEELS AND DEALS (Expected publishing date October 2017 in Pole to Pole "Dark Luminous Wings" Anthology)
    TRANSUBSTANTIATION (Expected publishing date September 2017, Issue #104 of Aurealis Science Fiction & Fantasy)
    GWI'SHIN (Published September 2016 in Eastlit Journal)
    MOMENTUM (Published 2014 & 2015 as Issue #3, and as part of an anthology in Tokyo Yakuza.)
    CHINGU (Published 2013, Issue #2, in Tincture Journal)
    Website: A Crow's Flying

  7. #632
    practical experience, FTW sockycat's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2016
    Location
    Michigan
    Posts
    297
    Quote Originally Posted by Denevius View Post
    So obviously I prefer the first version, and feel this is a step backward. Personally, I don't find the first version to be infodumpy. You were introducing a character, and you said who the character was. The ICRML. To me, there's nothing telly about that that should be avoided, as you then continue right into the present moment situation: the resettlement of the human race.
    Ack, conflicting feedback! I appreciate the honesty. I will see if I can find a happy medium between the two.
    "Seashells", Aphelion, May 2017

Page 26 of 26 FirstFirst ... 1620212223242526

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Custom Search