Why Is Reading Beneficial ?

Status
Not open for further replies.

quicklime

all out of fucks to give
Banned
Joined
Jul 15, 2010
Messages
8,967
Reaction score
2,074
Location
wisconsin
… suspect you’re right. Thing is, there’s not that direct correlation when it comes to writing as there is with other professions like being a doctor.

.


perhaps sports offer a better analogy--we all know the "wunderkind" stories of the skateboard phenom who, at twelve, picked up his first board and rode down his mother's car with it.....but here's the things:

1. Those stories are few and far between. There is far less "gross natural talent" than there is "aptitude" which, with discipline, can be cultivated into something greater. Life, as you mentioned, is part of that cultivation. So is writing. So is reading. (only bolded because that is the most relevant part for this discussion)

2. Let's take our skateboard wunderkind again....everyone likes those stories, but the "natural talent" folks still almost never are--that kid maybe danced, wakeboarded, was in karate and gymnastics, etc. Again, reading is an important part of training to write--you need stories, sure, but you don't think King actually jaunted, lived through an apocalypse, fought vampires and werewolves, and knew someone with a gypsy curse, do you? And even if he did, or if you make the very reasonable argument that these elements are often just crucibles for King, who likes to write about people more than anything, reading can teach you things about the breadth of material out there, about pacing, what good and bad dialogue look like, etc....things that you can't get as quickly in the vacuum of self-analysis alone.

3. Most of the big players get that way by practice. Sometimes it is oblique, like with the skater above. Often, it isn't, it just gets forgotten. Jordan is considered a wunderkind....except MJ never was. I remember hearing he was lackluster at first in college, but he also WORKED. The day his team was out of the playoffs, he was already practicing for next season. That was who he was...and the same story said he could be a driven, arrogant asshole. But the point was, he wasn't this guy who waltzed in and kicked ass....he put in his time. Lots of it. And again, reading is one of the places you do your time learning what is out there, finding things that work and things that don't. It isn't the only place, no, but I don't think it is at all unreasonable to suggest without it, you must work far harder to get to the top in your other areas--MJ could have only worked on dunking, or free throws, or passing, and omitted whole sections of the game, but you wouldn't call that a prudent approach, I suspect. Reading may not be critical, but it is a major part of the process and by avoiding it you place a far greater premium on the other areas of your study.


you absolutely don't HAVE to read, or ever work on free throws, or train to increase batting proficiency. But it isn't usually a good idea in any highly competitive field to try to compete with gaping deficits. I think that would be what you do by not reading, and you diminish your own odds if you choose not to.
 

rwm4768

practical experience, FTW
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jan 12, 2012
Messages
15,472
Reaction score
767
Location
Missouri
Reading is beneficial because it gives you a template of how to write and become published. It also can give you new ideas.
 

Stacia Kane

Girl Detective
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jul 23, 2006
Messages
8,142
Reaction score
2,668
Location
In cahoots with the other boo-birds
Website
www.staciakane.com
Anyone ever seen the movie BLAST FROM THE PAST? It's an utterly charming film; kooky dad during the Cuban Missile Crisis believes "the big one" hit, runs to his fallout shelter with his very pregnant wife, and locks them in for 35 years. Their son is born and grows up in the fallout shelter.

There's a bit in the movie where, in the shelter, the father is attempting to teach his son (Adam) the rules of baseball. He explains the rules but Adam just doesn't quite get it.

Later Adam leaves the shelter to get supplies etc. He meets a girl who takes him around LA. She takes him to a baseball game. There's a moment of Adam standing up crowing, "Of course! He runs because he must! NOW I get it!"

Trying to write a novel without reading them is like having the rules of a sport explained to you without ever actually seeing a game played. You might intellectually understand, but until you see those rules and concepts in practice I just don't believe you're going to fully "get it."

You can read all the how-to books in the world when it comes to writing, but without practical application, without seeing how tone and structure work, without--this is especially important IMO--really seeing "voice" and understanding how one voice differs from another, I just do not believe one can write a worthwhile novel. If you don't truly understand what those things accomplish and how they come together as a whole, how can you put them to good use?


And yes, as was pointed out above, reading is fantastic inspiration, if nothing else.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.