My two cents

The composition of the photo and values of the first one just drop it out of the mix for me. I like it individually, of them all I think it is one of the strongest because of the composition and the symbolism--but also of them all it doesn't fit.

The second and fourth have the most connection with each other. The third does not read right off as a wonderland character, I am guessing it is the white queen, but only guessing.

I am going to shoot down the gradient on the title font as well and steer you toward looking at it either all red or all white and see how that feels to you.