- Joined
- Feb 3, 2011
- Messages
- 2,669
- Reaction score
- 588
ETA He's tweeting about each pitch too, lol.
That explains the "full pitch here" tweet from WoCETA He's tweeting about each pitch too, lol.
Oh Lord. More things for me to stalk while at work, lol.
At least he's giving lots of feedback! Some agents have just been giving like 2-3 sentences.
Yeah, the tone is going to be a matter of opinion, and, as I repped you yesterday, I loved it, so I wouldn't really worry about that part of his comment and just take any other of his notes that make sense to you.
At least he's giving lots of feedback! Some agents have just been giving like 2-3 sentences.
Awww, sorry, Netz. I'm glad you've got a good attitude about it. It really is subjective.
Got my feedback. He didn't rip me a new one, which was a relief, but the only real feedback was that he didn't like my title. Which is interesting. Nobody's mentioned that before. At any rate this kind of confirms my suspicions that I've written a book nobody really wants to read. Sigh. Thank God for the new WIP, which I'm really psyched about
I didn't realise you were a fellow AWer when I saw you on the WoC forums. I've added you to the list on the first page.
This made me think of somebody's mom saying "I don't like your tone, young lady." But in all honestly, I feel like that's not such a bad criticism. Somebody else will love the voice, I bet.He didn't like my tone.
(The query is true to the tone of the book...)
Hang in there! Have you subscribed to your thread so it'll email you once she finally responds? That really helped me through the last 24 hours of waiting. Although I did a lot of compulsive checking too, just in case the email got lost.Ok, my person is officially torturing me, lol. I'm still next, and she's been offline since yesterday. Boo.
Niiicola, was yours the one he said was dark fantasy/horror? That did sound pretty cool. And yeah, the title thing threw me. It fit.
Ok, my person is officially torturing me, lol. I'm still next, and she's been offline since yesterday. Boo.
At least people are going in and commenting on some pitches that haven't had an agent comment yet
This made me think of somebody's mom saying "I don't like your tone, young lady."
At least people are going in and commenting on some pitches that haven't had an agent comment yet
EDIT: Wait. WTF? She skipped me. She's back, and went from 10 to 8. I'm 9. What. The...... *sigh* Let me know when I can get paranoid now, k?
It's interesting how some agents' sections are getting a lot of comments from non-agents--both on queries that the agent has and hasn't commented on--and others aren't being touched at all.
Yup, someone did that for me, bless her little heart. Not a Beowulf reader, since she didn't get the Grendel ref, but she liked my opening.
Gotta go find that subscribe button. Gonna be another long day tomorrow.
EDIT: Wait. WTF? She skipped me. She's back, and went from 10 to 8. I'm 9. What. The...... *sigh* Let me know when I can get paranoid now, k?