Okay, inspired by Be Franks list, here's mine.
In high school:
1. I went to Sophomore Slide (girl's choice dance) with a guy named Jack Black (not the famous actor).
2. My band teacher's name was Richard Long--he went by Dick.
3. I took vocal lessons from a woman named Paige Wright.
Nothing stands out as being far-fetched here. There are probably a lot of Jack Blacks in the world. #2 is a double entendre, but it's actually a common sort of name. I dunno. I'm gonna say #3 is the lie! though I can't explain why.