I would never name nor shame anyone and I would certainly hope that the forces of law and order would deal with anyone who makes such threats.
However, whilst this is an extreme case, it is sadly not the only one I have heard of some of which involve reviewers contacting and threatening authors. Indeed my very real fear is that at some point someone is going to tip over the edge and we will have a serious issue to contend with.
But this isn't simply an issue of authors reacting badly to reviews, it's much bigger than that. It's authors failing to understand what reviews actually mean and how to deal with them (or not as the case may be) as well as failing to understand the responsibilities they have to potential readers when they put work up for sale. It's also about reviewers pushing buttons to provoke reactions whilst hiding behind a cloak of perceived anonymity.
And that's just the start!
Given their track record includes publishing real names, locations, and where people work I assumed that your offer meant that you were intending to help them do this - I'm very pleased to hear you're not going to stoop that low.
Also, I had a look at the STGRB post about Emily Giffin. They really aren't criticizing Giffin, they're just saying she didn't handle the "bullies" who are picking on her well.
Loved this too:
Now, Melissa Douthit has been pretty quiet these past couple months, staying out of all the chaos swirling around the book community, which is why we were surprised to see her finally break her silence and step in to set the record straight:
Wow, I'm totally
fooledconvinced, aren't you?
You can posit the existence of a hierarchy without being contemptuous of those you may perceive* as lower down in it than yourself, surely? Do you think Uncle Jim is also slamming the Great Unpublished like myself who might well envy someone in, say, his position?
*rightly or wrongly
Ok, I read the post regarding the Amazon Review Mafia (rly?). Is it really that surprising, on the face of it, that there should be an overlap in membership between here, GR, and Amazon, which are all are sites about...books*?
(*yes, Amazon sells other things too, I know)
Last edited by Buffysquirrel; 08-24-2012 at 02:52 AM. Reason: a different thought popped up
It's no secret that I gave my permission for them to do that nor is it any secret that I've corresponded with the owners of the site. Indeed, I've just commented on a thread there.
I've nothing to hide, I'll talk to anybody about this issue because I want to try and bring about some kind of resolution for the good of both reviewers and authors. After all, damage is being done to both sides here and no one is winning. Least of all publishing.
However, what I will say with regard to STGRB is that whilst IF TRUE not everything they've done in the past would sit comfortably with me, I certainly don't believe all of the negative hype about them. Indeed, I've seen plenty of equally unacceptable things posted on both Amazon and Goodreads yet they have passed by with barely a comment.
At the end of the day, it's all very well for reviewers to condemn authors who react badly to negative reviews, but no one forces the reviewers to react to those comments. Maybe if a few people remembered that, we'd have less problems to worry about.
But I'm fascinated. Could you tell me which reviewers called up which authors at home to tell them to commit suicide? Could you mention which reviewers posted which authors' home addresses and suggested that they should be "stopped"?
There's a good side and a bad side here. And STGRB is on the bad side. Those who ally with her, who offer to help her, join her on the bad side.
To repeat myself I do not advocate the posting of personal information on the internet in any way shape or form. However, it is also worth noting that if people go on the attack, they have to understand that one day someone is going to turn round and fight back. Sometimes, that person will fight dirty, it's human nature. So the best thing to do is not attack.
Last edited by DBrimson; 08-24-2012 at 03:53 AM.
Do enlighten us. We're all very active readers who pay attention to blogs, reviews, publishers and authors, Amazon, Goodreads, we're all over, so please tell us the startling facts you are in possession of which we have overlooked.
This "everyone looks equally bad" crap is just that - crap. It's what the people on the bad side always say. Sure, of course there are reviewers who are assholes and write stupid things. But there is a huge differential here.
I did some of the work for you DB, and I don't think it's much in your favor.
I found his original thread on Amazon. Here
It's freakishly long and somewhere towards the end it gets way off track but the first couple pages are very much like it's been here for the last few.