I'd like some Roundtable advice.
An acquaintance asked me to critique his novel, which he hopes to have ready to query in the next few months. In my opinion, the ms is very raw and it was hard for me to even point to a central plot. I've tried to advise him to change specific things, because if I told him everything that was wrong it would be overwhelming.
I don't want to crush his dream here, and it's entirely possible I'm wrong. So should I just tell him to go ahead and query? I think the lit agents will reject his work, but they may not provide him any feedback.
This is tricky. What does the Roundtable think? Thanks for the help.
An acquaintance asked me to critique his novel, which he hopes to have ready to query in the next few months. In my opinion, the ms is very raw and it was hard for me to even point to a central plot. I've tried to advise him to change specific things, because if I told him everything that was wrong it would be overwhelming.
I don't want to crush his dream here, and it's entirely possible I'm wrong. So should I just tell him to go ahead and query? I think the lit agents will reject his work, but they may not provide him any feedback.
This is tricky. What does the Roundtable think? Thanks for the help.