- Joined
- Oct 9, 2010
- Messages
- 2,126
- Reaction score
- 342
I'm sure I've said it before, but seeing a couple of generic five-star reviews obviously written by friends or family or someone who hasn't even read the book is enough to make me not only not buy a book, but be highly annoyed.
I don't see the "like" thing as all that different. Like movieman said, all it does is make it less reliable for me and I'll stop trusting it.
Agreed.
I always look at the source of the reviews if there aren't many. Popular books are a bit different, for obvious reasons, but self-pubbed books (and honestly, some small press stuff I've seen) that have 3 or 5 or 8 5-star reviews so often will have most or all of those written by someone who has never reviewed another book on Amazon, or reviewed only one or two things right before or after reviewing that.
It only takes a glance. It's also pretty telling when you hit a small press book by someone with a fairly popular name in writing circles that has tons of glowing reviews. Read the few negative ones, and they almost always say something about being fooled by the tons of positive reviews. I've even some that said the writers group of writing buddies or podcast listeners must have been all the reviewers. The negative ones are more likely to be from people who review stuff regularly, too, in my experience.
I wonder how many non-writer readers check the reviewers' histories, though?
Shelley