We're Forever Blowing Bubbles

dclary

Unabashed Mercenary
Poetry Book Collaborator
Requiescat In Pace
Registered
Joined
Oct 17, 2005
Messages
13,050
Reaction score
3,524
Age
55
Website
www.trumpstump2016.com
Let's see what Bastiat had to say about that, Zoombie, from here.

And there's where the problem begins. As I described in the OP, all the "unintended" consequences of the Cash for Clunkers program were easily foreseen, because basic economics made them easy to foresee. But when those who foresaw them pointed them out, they were ignored. Why? Let's ask Robert K. Merton.

Politicians garner their support by "doing something" and thereby claiming credit for solving some social problem. By willfully sweeping the "unintended" consequences of that action under the rug, they can get credit for what they "fixed" in this cycle, and set up future problems that will, surprise, surprise, need the future intervention of those same politicians to fix. All this was described for C4C in the OP.

Let's walk through a simple example.

If I buy a banana, I give up some cash, the banana seller gets some cash, I get a banana -- and no distortion is introduced into the economy. So unintended consequences are low.

But if government takes money from some people and gives it to other people so that they can buy bananas, a whole raft of market distortions take place, and those each have their own unintended consequence.

The government has to get its money from somewhere. So it either borrows it, making a debt the citizens have to pay for later, or it prints it, which makes each dollar the citizens already hold worth less, and causes inflation, or it taxes it, which means that people who perhaps had planned to buy a tomato can no longer do so, because that money has left their budget.

Each of those methods causes unintended consequences. For brevity, let's just look at the last one. Because more bananas are sold, the banana growers think the market is larger than it really is, so they plant more banana trees and hire more banana pickers. When the artifically-fueled demand disappears next season, bananas rot on the trees and banana pickers get laid off.

Meanwhile, tomato growers lose business, see a declining market, and plant less and hire less next season.

Never fear, though. Next season, when there's a glut of bananas on the market, and tomato prices go through the roof from reduced supply, the politicians will come swooping in with price supports for the banana industry and price controls on the tomato crop. Those actions will cause further distortions that will have to be dealt with at a later date.

And those new solutions to problems that wouldn't have existed save for distortions introduced last cycle give politicians more power than they had before this whole cycle began.

And THAT is what I mean when I speak of "unintended consequences."

The game of politics cannot create wealth, it can only move it around. Politics, therefore, is a zero-sum game. For every winner, there's a loser. That's the one dirty secret that politicians don't want people to realize, and it's the single most important reason for the obfuscation of "Keynesian economics."

That Robert Merton quote, ftw, explains in a perfect nutshell exactly why we went to Iraq.
 

Synonym

Super Member
Registered
Joined
May 12, 2009
Messages
24,038
Reaction score
4,491
Location
Kansahoma
It explains nearly everything that the government does. Past and present included.
 

tjwriter

Emerging Anew
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Feb 13, 2005
Messages
11,983
Reaction score
3,256
Location
Out of My Mind
Website
www.kidscoffeechaos.wordpress.com
That was even before coffee, Syn. :) It's brewing now.

I so love you for this post.

I'm reading headlines and all in one day it goes something like this:

GM Expanding Production as a Result of Cash for Clunkers Program!

Cash for Clunkers Program ENDS Monday at 8PM!

I sat there scratching my head. By the time the newly produced cars make it to the showroom, the program's over and there's no longer that demand factor there to motivate people to buy.

It wasn't hard to figure out.