One of my chapters was picked as the editors choice for science fiction on the critiquing web site Onlinve Writer Workshop for Science Fiction, Fantasy, and Horror. The review was critical about some elements, but found interesting elements, potential and enough of a "competent effort" to move the story forward.
http://writersinprogresswip.blogspot.com/2011/10/editor-picked-my-submission-pointing.html
http://writersinprogresswip.blogspot.com/2011/10/editor-picked-my-submission-pointing.html