Here's my deal:
I've come to the conclusion that chapters 2 and 3 of my recently finished story are "false start." While they're necessary back story, very funny and build character, they really just don't seem to belong.
But my rather large number of beta readers said it would be a sin to cut them. Everyone seems to "love" these chapters. And my betas aren't just all friends of mine. I really trust their opinions.
Yet, an editor that I respect and work with agreed with ME, and told me to start with chapter 4.....
So, when do you keep a "false start?"
I hated Peter Jackson for cutting out Tom Bombadil!
I've come to the conclusion that chapters 2 and 3 of my recently finished story are "false start." While they're necessary back story, very funny and build character, they really just don't seem to belong.
But my rather large number of beta readers said it would be a sin to cut them. Everyone seems to "love" these chapters. And my betas aren't just all friends of mine. I really trust their opinions.
Yet, an editor that I respect and work with agreed with ME, and told me to start with chapter 4.....
So, when do you keep a "false start?"
I hated Peter Jackson for cutting out Tom Bombadil!