- Joined
- Apr 21, 2007
- Messages
- 1,647
- Reaction score
- 344
- Location
- Wisconsin
- Website
- womeneverywhere.wordpress.com
Just finished 'before i die' by jenny downham and my pillow is saturated by tears.
So I'm rereading C1TY OF BONES after a gap of several years, and there are so many revelations and de-revelations and re-revelations about people's parents throughout the series that I'm really confused. Who is the blond man whom Jocelyn claims is her dead husband, whose picture is on the wall, whose mementoes are in a box marked JC? If she made him up, it's kind of creepy that she gave her fictional dead husband the initials of her son. Why does everyone seem to think Michael Wayland is Jace's father? Jace in particular has so many parent revelations I can't keep up - it's Michael Wayland, no, it's Valentine, no, it's Stephen Herondale, ... Any Mortal Instrum3nts fans who can straighten me out here?
It's all explained later in the series, if you havent read the others, then you need to! lol. i don't want to spoil it. well.. i guess i could... dont read if you dont want spoilers.
>>>>> JC is Jonathan, who is actually a guy called "Sebastion" later on in the series. He obviously changes his name, and pretends to be a friend of the lightwoods. His real name is Jonathan, and is Valentines real son. Whereas Jace was the adopted son. i hope that helps. <<<<
So I'm rereading C1TY OF BONES after a gap of several years, and there are so many revelations and de-revelations and re-revelations about people's parents throughout the series that I'm really confused. Who is the blond man whom Jocelyn claims is her dead husband, whose picture is on the wall, whose mementoes are in a box marked JC? If she made him up, it's kind of creepy that she gave her fictional dead husband the initials of her son. Why does everyone seem to think Michael Wayland is Jace's father? Jace in particular has so many parent revelations I can't keep up - it's Michael Wayland, no, it's Valentine, no, it's Stephen Herondale, ... Any Mortal Instrum3nts fans who can straighten me out here?
I've read the whole series, but this stuff still doesn't make any sense. Why would Jocelyn Fray create a fictional husband, but name him after her son? Why would you make up a backstory about marrying and having sex with your own child? And illustrate this backstory with a picture of a handsome blond man? And sigh lovingly over a lock of his hair? That's creepily incestuous.
I know, but it's only fiction, and you can't read too much into it, otherwise we'd all drive ourselves nuts everytime we didn't understand something in a book. :/
IIRC, the blond dude Joyce has a picture of was just some random guy -- a neighbor, I think? Maybe someone she dated briefly when she first left the Shadowhunter world (forget what it's called) who happened to have those initials (or maybe I'm making that up)? As for Jace, you've got it right about his parentage, but I think the reason they thought he was originally a Wayland was because Valentine was pretending to be Michael Wayland after the failed coup. Hiding out in Wayland manor or something like that.
Does anyone know of any young adult books that take place entirely in a character's subconscious?
Started I am the Messenger today. I meant to read it while I was on vacation in July, but I didn't get around to it.
Loving it so far.
Oh my goodness, that book freakin' destroyed me. So lovely, so sad. It's been a few years since I read it, but I still get chills when I think of those last several pages.
Oh my goodness, that book freakin' destroyed me. So lovely, so sad. It's been a few years since I read it, but I still get chills when I think of those last several pages.
Not sure if I mentioned this already but I'm almost done with THE BOY BOOK by E. Lockhart, second in the Ruby Oliver series (and better than the first one, in my opinion).