a girl reading a draft of my book said, "i dont like this character's name (Linus). It doesnt really fit his personality." (Basically the name linus sounds dorky to her, and the character isn't really dorky at all).
this got me thinking, would this bother you? I am inclined to ignore the above criticism because in real life, peoples names dont necessarily match their personality; they were given at birth and people's names have little effect on their development, IMHO, compared to nurture and nature.
personally i like to choose names that are symbolic in some way, but not necessarily totally matching. I chose linus because he has a rigid personality, like a line. And he ultimately walks a balanced path in life; he walks a line. (this is never even remotely spelled out for the reader, it's just my thoughts in choosing the name).
anyway, does it bother you when a character's name doesnt fit your stereotype for it?
My personal thoughts are that the reader's stereotypes are their problem. The character's name is Linus. Deal with it.
this got me thinking, would this bother you? I am inclined to ignore the above criticism because in real life, peoples names dont necessarily match their personality; they were given at birth and people's names have little effect on their development, IMHO, compared to nurture and nature.
personally i like to choose names that are symbolic in some way, but not necessarily totally matching. I chose linus because he has a rigid personality, like a line. And he ultimately walks a balanced path in life; he walks a line. (this is never even remotely spelled out for the reader, it's just my thoughts in choosing the name).
anyway, does it bother you when a character's name doesnt fit your stereotype for it?
My personal thoughts are that the reader's stereotypes are their problem. The character's name is Linus. Deal with it.