PDA

View Full Version : Book "Publicists"


Lauri B
04-14-2005, 07:50 PM
Hi all,
I received the following unsolicited email from a publicity firm yesterday. I'm copying it here for a few reasons (see below):

Good Afternoon,
Contrary to popular opinion we have found that with the right angle and publicist the media is interested in new, self-published, and niche authors. Our team has proof and would like to help your authors more effectively reach their target audience, and achieve sault after media coverage at our affordable price. We would like to team up with your publishing company by offering your authors a generous publishers discount on our services.



The Spotlight Publicity team had been working exclusively with one major self-publishing company in the U.S., now that our exclusivity contract has expired; we have established our own business and services that are now available to all authors. We’ve created and implemented highly successful publicity services through our experience as publicists, as can be seen in our company press kit. Please contact us if you're interested in discussing this opportunity and receiving our press kit for further consideration. Thank you in advance for your time and consideration.

We look forward to speaking with you!




1. Publicity agents need to have an impeccable presentation, which includes (at the very least) good grammar and spelling skills. See for yourself what this company offers.
2. This company's web site won't release the names of any of its clients, citing their clients' privacy. Since the whole reason for a publicity agent's existence is to get clients' names and books out there, this is a huge red flag.
3. Their fees are very high for what they offer. A good publicist may well charge up to $5,000 per book launch, but this company offers a 15-week publicity "package" for what will amount to sending out review copies and press kits. You can do this yourself, if you're a self-published author, and you can subscribe to Bacon's Media Service for a few thousand dollars a year and save the middleman.
4. If you are a traditionally published author, your publisher should work with you on a publicity plan that takes into account both their marketing/publicity budget and your promotional skills and ideas: it should never be all up to you, and it will never be all up to your publisher. But hiring a publicist such as the company that solicited me just doesn't make sense, and it really irritated me to receive such a rotten pitch.

CaoPaux
04-16-2005, 12:12 AM
And spammers besides. Blech. Is this company one already mentioned on the Bewares Board? If not, please post their info there so we can warn folks away. :hat:

Howard Gross
04-18-2005, 07:17 AM
Nomad & CaoPaux:

It appears your warning is warranted. See this link on scams.net: http://www.scams.net/showthread.php?t=143

Cheers,
Howard

victoriastrauss
04-20-2005, 07:45 AM
Nomad & CaoPaux:

It appears your warning is warranted. See this link on scams.net: http://www.scams.net/showthread.php?t=143I agree the warning is warranted. As Nomad very cogently pointed out, this doesn't look like a professional company. But I wouldn't put a lot of credence in that post on scams.net (the same person seems to have made a similar post to another scam site). Two complaints would be interesting, and three would start to look like a pattern. But a single angry post that offers no specifics can as easily be sour grapes as a real complaint.

Unfortunately there are a lot of less-than-professional publicists. Another is Phenix & Phenix, which used to specialize in small press and self-pubbed authors but now appears to be mostly focusing on the books they put out through their vanity publishing operations.

- Victoria

Lauri B
04-25-2005, 04:41 PM
I appreciate that panic causes people to do things quickly and carelessly, but soliciting business is not something that should be done in a panic. I have no reason to think you're a scam, and didn't imply that you were--rather, I said that receiving an unsolicited email with many grammar and spelling errors from a publicist who also couldn't provide any references wasn't a publicist I would ever use or could ever recommend. I wish you the best of luck with your business and hope that you untangle your legal issues. It doesn't sound like a lot of fun.

hoyateach
05-12-2005, 08:57 AM
Um... are people allowed to advertise here?

Lauri B
05-12-2005, 04:58 PM
Nope. Not on this forum, anyway.

hoyateach
05-13-2005, 11:58 PM
Nope. Not on this forum, anyway.

Then shouldn't the publicist's posting above be deleted or this thread closed? Not sure what the rules are...

Alphabeter
05-14-2005, 05:56 AM
Jenna has allowed other posts from companies rebutting claims made on this board to stand.

Yes, its advertising, but after having read the initial post and then the company's reply, I am more disinclined to go with this company than if I had just read the first message.

Sometimes the companies need to "help" themselves with their reputations.

Howard Gross
05-21-2005, 06:33 PM
I agree with Joy 100%. The reply probably hurts their image more than the e-mail spam discussed in the original thread. Regardless if this company is any good or not, they’re not too bright to bring up issues such as “legalities”, “allegations”, and “fear of being sued” in a public forum. Duh! In addition, why would a “good” company publicly air their financial woes and go on to acknowledge they operate on a shoestring budget? I think their admission of hitting the ground running without a plan to know if and how they will pay their overhead is very telling.

But topping it all off, I sense a great deal of anger and frustration in the tone of their response. Although it may be warranted, it sure comes off as unprofessional, childish, and to some degree, comical.

Talented publicists? It's certainly not displayed in their writing or Web site copy.
Business Savvy? There are obviously no Einstein’s here.
Desperate Housewives? Probably says it all.